Rick Rubin
In addition to being a podcast host, Frederick Jay “Rick” Rubin is an American record producer and former co-president of Columbia Records. Along with Russell Simmons, he is the co-founder…
Gain access to ad-free versions of 20+ podcasts from the Pushkin library along with exclusive bonus episodes and other member benefits.
Mary Gauthier writes songs about people trying to make it through another day. Her characters wrestle with addiction, grieve the people they’ve lost, and look for something to believe in. She gives their stories the kind of care and attention that can make a stranger’s life feel intimately familiar.
On her new album, Reckoning, Gauthier takes inspiration from the spare sound and character-driven storytelling of Bruce Springsteen’s Nebraska. With little more than her voice, guitar, and harmonica, she explores moments when people have to confront the truth about their lives—and decide what comes next.
On today’s episode, Bruce Headlam talks with Mary about the mysterious process of finding her characters, writing with Vince Gill and Lori McKenna, and why changing a single word finally unlocked a song she’d been working on for more than a decade. She also shares how writing helped her recognize the lasting effects of her own childhood trauma—and why a sad song can leave us feeling a little less alone.
So the new album is called Reckoning. Can you talk a bit about the title and talk a bit about the thinking going into it?
00:18
Speaker 2
Yeah, the process of writing this record for me was quick. I'm a slow writer, a meticulous, think about what I'm writing for a long time kind of writer. So when songs start coming one after the other after the other, for me that's just highly unusual. And I think I was responding and reacting to what happened in Minneapolis this January when ICE took over the city and killed Rene Good and Alex Pretty. And those songs are a response to what I saw happening there. And I didn't have a title track. I had all the songs except for a title track and the song Reckoning, and I was I was just feeling like I needed to keep writing until something comes through that feels like a statement about the whole record, because I think that's what a title track of a record does. It tells you what the record's about. And I sat down with a young man who I think is extraordinary. His name is Aaron Lee Tashin in Nashville, and we were writing at my writing office, and I found an old song that I never completed called Reckoning. I said, you want to give this a go? I never got anywhere with this. And he came up with a really cool driving guitar part. And we started going. And about two and a half hours into the co-write, I started thinking this might be the title track. And the further we went, the more I became convinced this is it. This is a summation of what all these songs are saying and doing. And... Upon reflection, I think the songs and the record are stories of people at a turning point, a place of reckoning. You know, I think it's a bit of an ominous word to most people. They're like, oh, that's heavy. Like, well, it can be. It can also be liberating. We reach places in our life where there's consequences, and nations reach places where In their history, where there's consequences. It's an individual and societal and national and international phenomenon. And I think that's what reckonings are, is a confrontation with consequences. And these stories are all about that.
02:39
Speaker 1
Now, we're making this sound like a very political album, full of polemic. It's not.
02:45
Speaker 2
These are....
02:47
Speaker 1
Almost more so than some of your other albums, they're character-driven stories.
02:51
Speaker 2
Yeah, they're character-driven stories in the spirit of Springsteen's Nebraska, really. Voice guitar, harmonica, stripped-down stories. The characters are dealing with what's happening, and there's a political component to their reflection and to the impact on them, but this is not a collection of protest songs by any means.
03:14
Speaker 1
You mentioned Nebraska. I have a rule when I'm going to interview someone that I listen to their new work without reading anything about it. I don't read the publicity stuff that comes in. I don't read reviews. I want to absorb it first. And when I heard it, I thought Nebraska, but more the sound. And I guess now that I think about it, the character-driven songs as well, which there's a lot in Nebraska. Was that a deliberate choice on your part? Were you thinking Nebraska when you wrote this and recorded it?
03:42
Speaker 2
I started thinking Nebraska about six songs in. as I was writing, and I started thinking, I don't want a band on this one. I don't want a producer, really. I need an engineer, and I need someone to help me get my best vocals, but I don't want complexity around the recording. I want it to be voice, guitar, harmonica, and that is, to me, Nebraska. And I thought, you know, the best way in the quickest way and I think the fundamentally right way to do these songs is stripped down and I think they're strong enough to hold a listener without embellishment and that's how I want to do it and of course that's I think Nebraska's one of Bruce's if not Bruce's absolute strongest records and it holds up 50 years later he could have put it out tomorrow and still become a masterpiece and timely And I love the way that it captures the intensity of what he was going through. Side note, I'm friends with Warren Zanes, who wrote a book about the making of Nebraska. And I absolutely love the movie that came from that book. It was really, I think, fantastic.
05:07
Speaker 1
How did you record it then? I mean, he recorded that famously on, I think, like an old, Tascam Porta Studio or some.
05:14
Speaker 2
He recorded it to cassette.
05:16
Speaker 1
To cassette. Yeah, yeah. How did you record this?
05:19
Speaker 2
Voice Guitar Harmonica in a little studio in Austin. We did it into Pro Tools. I brought it to Nashville. They added a few cinematic things. Nilsson Hubbard at the studio in Nashville added a few cinematic things. And then they ran it all through a Tascam recorder. They ran it through an analog tape recorder.
05:39
Speaker 1
Really?
05:39
Speaker 2
Uh-huh. And then dumped it down back into... digital and that's what gives it that 1980 sound it's it sounds analog and i i was just beside myself with joy that they just saw it was for sale on facebook marketplace and said let's give this a try because mary keeps saying nebraska and that's the way that one was recorded um and they got that quality of um It's bigger, analog. It has a nicer reverb in so many ways. The voices are the best vocal recording I've ever had of my voice because it feels uninterrupted. There's nothing between me and the listener. It's very exposed in a way, and I love that.
06:24
Speaker 1
Sounds like you can hear the room.
06:25
Speaker 2
You can hear the room.
06:27
Speaker 1
That's very cool.
06:28
Speaker 2
It's very cool, and the results are undeniable. It sounds great. Everybody's telling me how they do that. I said, I think that was like a $ 80 Tascam recorder they found on Facebook Marketplace or something like that.
06:44
Speaker 1
They had to tape their, you know, wire going into it. You mentioned that this in some ways was started off by what was going on politically. And the album is not a political album, but it does bring up an interesting question about politics and music that we want to think mix, but often really doesn't mix that well. As much as people talk about Masters of War by Bob Dylan, I'm not sure that's the song most people go to. How do you deal with your angry over a political situation? How does that find its way into songs?
07:21
Speaker 2
For me, the most effective way to get to it as a songwriter, for me, is through story. And I'm not trying to argue or convince. I'm just showing through the lens of one person's humanity how their life is impacted by what's going on. You know, there's a song on the record called Judgment Day, and it's written from the perspective of a young priest, a newly ordained priest. I read an article about a bishop in New Hampshire. His name is Rob Hirschfeld, who gave a sermon, a liturgy. I don't know the correct words. But after Renee Goode was killed point blank in the head, shot in her driver's seat, he spoke to that in front of his parishioners. And he talked of the long history of Christian martyrdom, of priests putting themselves on the line to stand between abuse of power and people who were being abused and assaulted. And the headline was Episcopal Bishop Calls for New Martyrs. And so that just captivated me. And I imagined myself a young priest listening to my boss telling me to get my affairs in order. And what would that be like? And so... I spoke to a Catholic priest that I knew in Houston who married my nephew, and we had a good two-hour conversation helping me get into the psyche of what it would be like to be a young priest at that juncture. So I created this character who has to make a decision. Am I going to do what I'm being asked? Am I brave enough to do that? And so that's political, but it's also deeply personal. Will he do it? And honestly, Bruce, I didn't know what he was going to do until the last line of the song.
09:24
Speaker 1
Is that often the case with your writing? You don't know where it's going?
09:28
Speaker 2
That is often the case.
09:30
Speaker 1
There's another song which interested me for the same reason, which is Soldier of Fortune, looking at the other side of this, in which you write about the Roman soldiers who killed Christ, and you relate them to Gestapo and to ICE agents.
09:46
Speaker 2
Can you talk a little about that? Yeah, they have a lot in common, I think. I think there's a thread through history of this personality type. This idea came, I was looking at my nephew's wedding. I was looking at the stained glass depictions of the stations. of the Cross and the Roman guards' treatment of Christ on his way to his execution. You know, they're gambling for his clothes. They're throwing on a crown of thorns. He's fallen to his knees. They're mocking him, mimicking him, and abusing him. It just looks so familiar to me. I went, oh, my God. Roman guards, ice. These are the same guys. Same personality type. You know, the Roman guards are poorly trained, empowered soldiers working for Pontius Pilate. And I think that the song is an angry song.
10:40
Speaker 1
It sounds like an angry song.
10:41
Speaker 2
I was angry when I wrote that. And I wrote that with Eliza. It's like, how dare these people? Step in front of a car, accuse the driver of running him over, and be allowed to shoot point blank in a person's face. No accountability, you know? So that definitely was written in anger and outrage, more than anger. There's an outrage to these behaviors that just triggers me and to the core of my being.
11:08
Speaker 1
Here's why I struggled with that song. Because it was written by you, that you have referred to your guitar as as an empathy machine, which I think is a lovely play on the old Woody Guthrie, this machine kills fascists. I wonder, did you consider a song where you would have some empathy for the soldiers? Is that possible?
11:35
Speaker 2
I do think it's possible. I could get inside a troubled ice agent's heart and write from that perspective. I couldn't find empathy for their rage, but I could find characters that I could write from. That particular song, I called my friend Eliza Gilkyson because she's so good at writing these scathing political songs that call people out. And that's what I was in the mood for at that point. And yeah, that song, you know, I don't play it much because it is not really what I do. It's not my voice really. It's something that I felt I needed to do, a responsibility really to do, to articulate the through line. But it was to me kind of a catch and release. Okay. You know, oh, I got one of these. Reel it in, put it on the boat, throw the line back in. Right. I'm not going to go down that road too far because that's really not my greatest strength as a writer.
12:43
Speaker 1
Now that I'm thinking about it, the first time we met, you had just done Rifles and Rosary Beads.
12:49
Speaker 2
Yeah.
12:50
Speaker 1
Which is because you partner with, I'm not sure what branch of the armed forces, but you do a program called Songwriting with Soldiers. Yeah, yeah.
12:59
Speaker 2
I wrote for a little over 10 years with veterans that served in all branches of the military and helped them articulate their mostly trauma stories.
13:07
Speaker 1
Yeah.
13:07
Speaker 2
Yeah.
13:08
Speaker 1
It's incredible to me that.
13:12
Speaker 1
Writing with you, they could replay some incredibly dark times, but that was very cathartic for them.
13:17
Speaker 2
Oh, yeah.
13:17
Speaker 1
Yeah.
13:18
Speaker 2
Alchemy, really. Yeah. It takes that traumatic blow and alchemizes it into something that's useful for other people and helpful in the world to explain war. And it turns it into something that's purposeful.
13:35
Speaker 1
And useful for them.
13:36
Speaker 2
Oh, yeah.
13:37
Speaker 1
Which is the amazing part.
13:39
Speaker 2
Yeah, because they realize, oh, my God, this song can be of service. These are volunteers, right? They volunteered to serve. They weren't drafted. So once they realized their song could be of service, that was a great relief for them. And it gave them something. I mean, this is why I write songs, I think, is because I understand that my songs can be useful, and I need to be of service. in a way that alchemizes my own story, that turns the struggles of my own experience, especially as a young child, into something that is art and useful in the world, that helps people who are not able to find the words. And that's what the veterans did and are still doing through a program called Songwriting with Soldiers.
14:32
Speaker 1
Are you still involved with it?
14:33
Speaker 2
Sometimes. Yeah, not like I was.
14:36
Speaker 1
It's interesting, you know, there's all these neuroscientists with theories about why sad songs make us feel better. And, you know, there are a lot of theories about art and particularly theater about why seeing trauma on stage is cathartic. You've written a lot of sad songs. Why is it? What's our attraction to those?
15:04
Speaker 2
Well, It's paradoxical. But I think there's a me too in those songs where people find themselves there and realize I'm not alone. Someone else feels this thing that I've felt. And, you know, I asked Willie Nelson that question. I got to open a bunch of shows for Willie, and I said... Willie, man, why are people drawn to the sad songs? What is it? He said, Mary, I reckon it's because they figure if it could happen to old Willie, it could happen to anybody. It's not that misery loves company, although it does. It's that life happens to everyone, no matter what your income or level of fame is. And I think that there is... hope in just the singing of a sad song. A person filled with despair is not going to sing or write a song. The hope is that there's an opportunity to try again. Well, this happened, but let's try again, you know? And I think that it's also transformative because you transform as the writer from the story. I'm not the story. I'm the writer. And writers have power. Writers have agency. Writers have the ability to write the ending differently. There's power in that.
16:44
Speaker 1
So even in songs, I'm thinking of a song like How You Learn to Live Alone, which is just a killer. And even though the ending suggests that there may not be hope of a next time, There's something even in that song that makes people feel hopeful, do you think?
17:05
Speaker 2
Well, I wouldn't draw a direct line to hopeful. It makes people who are learning how to live alone after a long time of being coupled. It helps people to know that others have survived it. We know how you feel. And there's a sun coming up tomorrow with possibility in it. Not necessarily for new love, but for a new life. There's rebirth every morning. And so there's a sense of we that helps the I. Yeah. We know. We understand. That is huge when you're going through terrible pain.
17:46
Speaker 1
You also believe, and this is very much like Springsteen, in the redemptive power of... music. Your book is literally called Saved by a Song.
17:58
Speaker 2
Yes.
17:58
Speaker 1
That doesn't come through so much in Springsteen's albums, but if you see him live.
18:02
Speaker 2
Oh, he's all about redemption.
18:05
Speaker 1
And how the old songs, like, you know, Eddie Floyd's Raise Your Hand, how that inspired him at a certain point, that that's what life was. Talk a little bit about that. How did you reach that conclusion?
18:19
Speaker 2
I don't know. I think it's something that is inherent in in the music that I love. You sing the truth at the top of your voice and you find your tribe. You find your people. And most importantly, you find your truth. And you shed the stories that have been planted in your brain by powers that want you silent. And you pull them out like weeds and write your own story. And, you know, there's liberation in that. there's so many layers of indoctrination that we have to, well, let's just put it in first person, that I have had to shed. And I'm still shedding. And coming to my own conclusions and coming to my own understandings of things, that's redemption. And then to bring it to people and they're like, yeah, me too. That is a communal redemption. That is a salvation from Solitude from isolation, from despair, removal, hopelessness. It's powerful. It's a powerful force.
19:37
Speaker 1
What's interesting in this album is a lot of these songs are about people close to the end of their lives.
19:42
Speaker 2
Yes.
19:43
Speaker 1
You like to joke about being old. You're not that old.
19:45
Speaker 2
No.
19:46
Speaker 1
You've got a long time to go.
19:47
Speaker 2
I hope so. What....
19:50
Speaker 1
Had you looked back and said, well, a lot of songs about people about to die, was there something going on that sparked those songs in you?
19:59
Speaker 2
No. I think those characters, I don't choose my characters. They choose me. I wish I could choose my characters. and say, I want to write a meaningful song about, I don't know, fill in the blank, this character. It doesn't work that way for me. It's a very strange, mysterious thing that I can't fully explain, but I feel tapped, like there's a tap on my shoulder, and that tap is a character wanting me to give them voice. And you'd think a writer has a choice over that, and I bet a lot of writers do. I don't. I can't bring the characters I decide to write into life. I have to write the characters that want to come through me. So I end up on a record with two elderly people who are at the end of their life. I ended up with a character that worked on the Orange Blossom special who's probably in his mid to late 90s if he's still alive. You know, a character that may or may not be facing, you know, hostile forces as he goes to stand with people against ICE. A song about despair of having lost someone in a song called Gone. You know, I wrote that with Beth Nielsen Chapman, and she's survived two husbands now. She's been widowed twice. And so that just filtered in to the song as well as I've lost many, many friends over the last five years. And that sense of loss is very real in the record. And it just comes with age too. You know, you don't have to be that old to start losing folks.
21:52
Speaker 1
Now you didn't sit down with Beth Chapman and say, You've lost two husbands. Let's write a song about loss. How did it filter into the session?
22:02
Speaker 2
Well, I think we try to find what we're feeling more than story-wise, like emotionally what we're feeling. And it's a wild goose chase. We run around the room looking for something and she usually is the one to pick up the guitar and and start plucking, and I'll stop and go, yes, that, that. That's the thing. Let's write words for that. And it just naturally migrates to what's on our heart.
22:34
Speaker 1
One of these songs, Sometimes, you mentioned, you had a very interesting tap on the shoulder. Can you tell that story?
22:42
Speaker 2
Yeah. Yeah, that one was a wild ride. I co-wrote that song with the great Vince Gill at his studio in Nashville.
22:51
Speaker 1
And, um, had you worked with him before?
22:54
Speaker 2
No, but I, the Nashville I moved to in 2001 was a pretty small town. So I'd see him at the Y I'd see him at the deli, you know, I'd see, I've seen him, I'd see him, um, at the Opry. I knew of Vince and we had a hello and he would walk up and tell me a joke kind of friendship. You know, he's, he's got a lot of good jokes and, um, I always wanted to write with him and, and, uh, I had the opportunity to do so and seized on it. And so I went over to his house, and he had an idea that he'd been sitting on for a long time that came from a discussion he had with Mavis Staples, which was something she said in the conversation. They were talking about probably race relations, politics. And she told him, Vince, son, we've seen some times, haven't we? And Vince said, Mary, I know it's a song. Sometimes. It's got to be a song in there. And he had... a melody and a few placeholder words. And in the words, he mentioned the Orange Blossom Special. I said, man, I know that's a train, but I don't know anything about it. Would you tell me about it? He said, oh, I just put it in there because it sounds good. I don't think it's about train. I said, well, why don't we go down in there and see what the Orange Blossom Special was? He said, well, it's a bluegrass song everybody plays, but it doesn't have anything to it. I'm like, it feels like something's there. So I looked it up. Turns out the Orange Blossom Special was a high-speed luxury train, rode from Manhattan to Miami in the 20s, 30s, 40s, into the early 50s, and then trains were done. And I found a black-and-white photo of a waiter in the dining car of the Orange Blossom Special. And it was a black man in a tuxedo preparing for a dinner service. Looked like silver china, linen, a very... high end luxury train, a fine dining experience for, for those eating there. And the, and the waiter in the picture looked like a man with a good job. Like he, he could, he'd probably take care of his family on the money he made working on that train. And it occurred to me, and I felt the tap, that tap we were just talking about. It occurred to me, he's seen some times and I asked him to tell me about it. And, uh, That's where it gets mysterious, you know, because I'm giving voice to this guy. And Vince and I are going back and forth and back and forth and back and forth. And we're about half in to what I think is going to be a really good song. And day is up. I go home. And then we start texting each other over the next two weeks with possible ideas. and his song zagged and mine zigged. We have different versions of this song, but the one thing that we stuck to together throughout was there was a school shooting in Nashville, uh, where, where, uh, it's called the covenant school where, where, where kids were killed and the principal was killed. Uh, and, uh, the principal happened to be one of my songwriting students. And, uh, a fellow Baton Rougean. She came to Nashville from Baton Rouge. I'm from Baton Rouge. And Vince was asked to sing at one of the kids' funerals, Somewhere Over the Rainbow, which she was supposed to be singing in the school play. And we were both just flattened by that school shooting. And him singing in that service, I don't know how he did it. He said, I don't know how I did it either. He said I had to dissociate. It was just incredibly difficult. And... The gun line stayed. There's an anti-gun line, and we stuck to that. Mine went a little further. I think his character and his imagination rode the train. My character and my imagination worked on the train. So we had two different guys going. But I loved the song, and Emmylou Harris sang it, which... Vince, I interviewed him for my podcast about this record. He said, you know, Mary, that's the first Demi song that I've ever written that she sang.
27:23
Speaker 1
Is that right?
27:24
Speaker 2
And it meant a lot to me. Wow. Like, you know what, Vince? It meant a lot to me, too. Oh, bad.
27:29
Speaker 1
Now, do you know her as well?
27:30
Speaker 2
I do. Yeah. Yeah.
27:35
Speaker 1
You know, we were talking about anger earlier in music, but this character is very philosophical. Not angry. It's not the song, someone looking over their lifetime of grievance. There's a beautiful moment. He talks about Obama.
27:53
Speaker 2
Yep.
27:53
Speaker 1
Getting elected. And then it's almost like a little coda after that. I can't remember the words precisely, but it was something to the effect that I saw the insurrection. And then the line after is so beautiful.
28:05
Speaker 2
Can't say I was surprised.
28:07
Speaker 1
Can't say I was surprised. Just tells you so much about the character. It tells you so much about everything you've heard up until that point. Do you remember writing that line? I do.
28:16
Speaker 2
Yeah. That's one of those lines that I call it a God line. It comes shooting through me when I'm doing something else and I just write it down. I don't know what I was doing. I was probably doing something in my office and sat down and that just came shooting through me. And I wrote it down and I thought, man, that guy's talking to me. I got to work this into what he's saying.
28:43
Speaker 1
When that happens, do you honestly feel a little lightning bolt?
28:47
Speaker 2
Yes. These are gifts from angels. We get credit and we certainly get the copyright.
28:54
Speaker 1
If you're lucky.
28:55
Speaker 2
We're lucky that it comes through us and to us. I, in all honesty and sincerity, can't say it came from me. I feel it came through me. You know when that happens. that that's got to work its way in to something that you're creating. And we're always hunters and gatherers for ideas and images and words and phrases. And so if something like that's happening and I'm in a conversation, I got to stop the conversation and write it down. Because these things come knocking at the damnedest times. You just, you know, you got to grab them. They're gifts. This is what inspiration is. It's not a.
29:39
Speaker 1
Do they always come when you're already working on a song?
29:42
Speaker 2
No, they come intermittently for no apparent reason. Guy Clark used to work on guitars while he was writing. So he'd write a little and then pick up the guitar and work on the wood and then write a little and pick up with the guitar and do a little gluing and sanding and then write a little. And he felt like occupying his mind on the guitar freed it up for anything to drop in that could help the song instead of sitting there just staring at the song and having nothing. And that toggle, I think, is a cool thing. Dali had a metal pot, and he'd sit in his nap chair and put a rock in his hand over the metal pot. And so when he went to doze deep enough that his hand dropped and the rock fell, He'd wake up and paint what he saw. We're always trying to prime the pump for these things that are mysterious gifts that artists receive that come from I don't know where.
30:40
Speaker 1
Some artists, Paul Simon is one of them, and one of your heroes, Leonard Cohen, is another. They do sit there at the blank page and they write and write and write and it takes them months.
30:52
Speaker 2
Me too.
30:52
Speaker 1
You're that kind of writer?
30:53
Speaker 2
Oh yeah, you get that one line and that's a gift. That's not a song. That's a good line. Now you've got to build something, and there's no crew to bring in. I've got to do all the things. Months is about right, definitely. Sometimes it took me and Vince probably eight months.
31:15
Speaker 1
Is that right? Mm-hmm. And are you the kind of writer who you write ten verses and select two?
31:22
Speaker 2
I'll overwrite, yeah. Yeah, I'll go past three or four verses and see if I can make it better, and then take parts and apply them to the weaker parts. I try to build a junkyard, and then I see what's shining and what's working. I want more than less. More rather than less is always good.
31:44
Speaker 1
But your songs are often the opposite. Their less is more. There's a couple of songs on here I'd can't remember which ones particularly but i think there's two verses.
31:55
Speaker 2
Well yeah that's how it sometimes ends up but i imagine i kept the best two or i built the best two and i thanked all the others for for their contributions and and put them back in the junkyard.
32:09
Speaker 1
So tell me about heaven hmm yeah i.
32:14
Speaker 2
Wrote that with lori mckenna one of the great american songwriters um And we wrote that. That was the first song for this record. And it was written in 2014, I think. And it wasn't right. We had played a show together in Berkeley. It was in Berkeley. I think it was the Freight and Salvage. And I had a friend come see me and sit with me backstage for a little while. And he was very, very ill. He had cancer. And he was very, very ill. He was a playwright. And we were working on something together. And when he stepped out and before we took the stage, Laurie said, he doesn't look so good. Is he going to be all right? I said, he's going to be all right if he believes in heaven. And she, you know, is a songwriter. She kept that. And I guess maybe eight, nine, ten months later, we were on Zoom for a co-write together, and she said, remember that thing you said about he's going to be all right if he believes in heaven? What if we write that? And so we did, and it was an imagined story. We created two elderly folks that had been married forever. And, you know, Lori's so good at that. I mean, she's been with her husband since she was in high school, you know. She's only been with one man her whole life, and she's so good at these long-term relationship songs. And I try to lean into my co-writer's strengths, and we– we kept that line. He's going to be okay if he believes in heaven. The wife passes and he's facing his ultimate demise. And 12 years go by, neither one of us recorded it, but we both know it's a good song, but there's something wrong with it. And I'm walking around the block with my earbuds on, going through old songs, trying to see if there's anything in my pile that could work on this record. And that song came through And it occurred to me that if we change the line, he's going to be all right if he believes in heaven too, he's going to be all right because he believes in heaven, it unlocks it.
34:25
Speaker 1
Tell me what that did for you when you thought of that.
34:28
Speaker 2
It was like, that's it. That's it. One word, and now we got it. You know, one word, 12 years, a lot of age happened, a lot of friends have passed, a lot of Wisdom on both of our parts has been gained in that time. We're in a very different place than the two people who wrote in 2014. And I called her up. I said, Lori, I think I got it. And she goes, oh, the because guy is a different guy than the if guy. Yeah. I said, yeah, he is. He's our guy. He's our guy.
35:09
Speaker 1
It creates a psychology.
35:11
Speaker 2
Oh, yeah.
35:13
Speaker 1
Yeah. And it lifts the song.
35:14
Speaker 2
And it lifts the guy. Yeah. Yeah, and he's got faith, and he can face what's happening with faith, which is not anything based in reason. Faith is, in many instances, irrational, but he has it, and it's going to make this less difficult for him. And I love this guy, and that's the guy. We missed it by one word, but we found him.
35:47
Speaker 1
Now, you grew up in a religious house.
35:49
Speaker 2
Catholic, yeah.
35:50
Speaker 1
Catholic. You're not religious now, particularly.
35:53
Speaker 2
No.
35:54
Speaker 1
But it is interesting that someone else's faith became so meaningful that it transformed the song for you.
36:01
Speaker 2
Yeah.
36:02
Speaker 1
Is that something you could have written 10, 20 years ago?
36:05
Speaker 2
I wouldn't have been comfortable. All I know is I've watched people in the last couple of years face their death with faith, and it's less terrifying. for them. I don't know how I'm going to be when I'm in that situation. But from what I've seen, if I got to choose, I would hope to have some kind of faith in some kind of eternity that's benevolent. It's not theological or religion that is going to give me faith. I think it's more, I don't know, these great lines that come from this great mystery. I want to go hang out there There's a mystery that.
36:51
Speaker 1
Are there more lines here?
36:53
Speaker 2
Hey, I'm here now.
36:54
Speaker 1
What have you got? Bring it on.
36:56
Speaker 2
You got any guitars? Yeah, there's a mystery I think I can believe in because I've had a dance with it for a lot of years now. But it doesn't come from church, although they're probably tapping into that or trying to or missing it completely. But I think at the end of the day, I can write characters with faith now much more comfortably.
37:19
Speaker 1
Interesting.
37:21
Speaker 2
Is that an age thing or is that a maturity thing or is that a wisdom thing?
37:25
Speaker 1
I don't know. I think, I mean, for me, I think probably my parents passing and they weren't particularly religious, but it made me more comfortable with that kind of language. Getting older, you know, not about facing my own mortality. It's not about that. I don't know, more accepting of other people.
37:44
Speaker 2
That too, allowing people to be how they are and And embracing that.
37:48
Speaker 1
Being less argumentative.
37:50
Speaker 2
Yeah. Yeah. Being in awe of how people make it through another day.
37:54
Speaker 1
Yes, I'm in awe of that. Tell me, that is a fantastic story, by the way. One word in 12 years, you said?
38:01
Speaker 2
14 or 12. A lot of years.
38:03
Speaker 1
You should call in another 12 years and say, hey, I've got another word change. We've got to re-record it. Tell me about Black Ice.
38:14
Speaker 2
Yeah, I wish I understood that one. That one is, it came from, I wrote that with Beth Nielsen Chapman. It came from a title. We started with a title, which Beth never, ever, ever likes to do. I had to convince her.
38:28
Speaker 1
Do you often start with titles?
38:29
Speaker 2
Yes, because it gives me something to aim at on the dartboard. I know where that little circle in the middle is. I got to have something to aim my lines at. And it can change. It's not permanent or it's not a commitment. But if I have something, then we can get going here. When I saw you this morning with my coffee there, we were changing the title with somebody.
38:52
Speaker 1
Is that right?
38:53
Speaker 2
Uh-huh. Okay.
38:54
Speaker 1
Yeah.
38:54
Speaker 2
Yeah. I was like, what if we call it, you know, alchemist instead of, I don't remember. But I think Beth is resistant because she likes the mystery and she likes the magic of just not having nowhere and no agenda and just seeing what we can come up with out of thin air. And it always happens. We come up with something. But I had black ice and it was really speaking to something on a cellular level with me. And I couldn't get to what it was, but I knew it was inside and I had to figure it out. And so we put our character in a car. and the car hits black ice. And so my job as a songwriter then is what is this metaphor and why are we doing this? And oh my God, that was a wild ride for me. It took months, months. I went down to Key West. I got a hotel room. I sat in the room. I stared at the water. I walked around the island. You know, I ended up like Leonard Cohen in the Songwriters on Songwriting book, in the corner of the room in my underwear, begging God for the word. Like, just give it to me. What is this about? And finally, I got to it. I think that character, which is me, is dealing with A form of PTSD. And I didn't know that's what I had. And I'm 64 now. I didn't know that's what it was. When I shut down completely and my eyes go dark and I'm not myself and there's a coldness that I can't explain.
40:32
Speaker 1
A coldness towards other people?
40:34
Speaker 2
Towards everything. It's a flash and it scares people. And I don't feel anything. It never occurred to me that that could be PTSD. And a decade of working with veterans who suffer with PTSD, studying with Dr. Bessel van der Kolk, one of the foremost experts on trauma, a Dutch doctor who lives in Boston who's become a friend of mine, who wrote The Body Keeps the Score. Bessel's the man. Got PTSD into the DSM after the Vietnam War, you know, studying with him. It never occurred to me that this Thing in me was that until I wrote this song. And I couldn't get to it without a chisel and a whole lot of wax to connect the dots, to connect the evidence with the behavior, with the understanding of the reality.
41:34
Speaker 1
I'm going to ask something on a very prosaic level, because you're from Louisiana, where I doubt they have a lot of black eyes. None. But you lived in Boston.
41:44
Speaker 2
Yeah.
41:45
Speaker 1
Did you ever spin out? No.
41:47
Speaker 2
To me, it was the vehicle to get to... Nobody chooses to go cold. This is a spin out. There's no direction you're going to turn the wheel correctly to stop this thing from going round and round.
42:03
Speaker 1
That's the other thing I remember from driving lessons was you spin... In the direction of the skid. Yeah. And I thought, well, I'm going backwards. Okay. Don't think my wheel goes quite that far.
42:15
Speaker 2
Yeah.
42:16
Speaker 1
How do I spin in that direction?
42:17
Speaker 2
What is the math of this? Yeah. Yeah, it's utter powerlessness, and you're going to land where you're going to land, and you can't, in that moment, do a damn thing. Mm-hmm.
42:29
Speaker 1
You've talked about your trauma. You wrote an incredible album about your adoption.
42:35
Speaker 2
Mm-hmm.
42:36
Speaker 1
But you never put it together with PTSD.
42:39
Speaker 2
No, never. I don't know. It seems obvious now. But boy, doesn't everything once we figure it out. Yeah.
42:47
Speaker 1
Was that a lightning bolt when you saw it? When you thought, wait a second. Yeah.
42:51
Speaker 2
Yeah. And it gave me two things. Songs give the songwriters things. And this one gave me compassion for myself. And an awareness that when this happens, it's not me, and I don't need to make decisions based on what's happening in that spin-out. That there is something that's come over me, the black ice, and it will pass, and I just need to get to the other side and not take it as a permanent reality, which it, of course, feels like.
43:33
Speaker 1
When that comes over you around other people, does it pass quickly?
43:38
Speaker 2
It can if we don't get into a spiral around it. What I have is a terror, absolute terror of abandonment. I spent a year without parents, and it was my first year on earth. I was in an orphanage in New Orleans in an overcrowded institution with a couple of nuns and a couple of hundred babies. So That is still in me. And sometimes it cries out and it sends me into that spiral. And it feels real and it feels like it's happening now. It's everything you hear about trauma. I just never put it together that this is what that was. And so, you know, since I wrote that song, I haven't had one of those episodes. And I know there'll be one because there's always another one coming at some point. But I hope when I'm in it, I can I don't know, run to the song or something. I need to remember this is not reality. This is a wound, and we'll get through it if we don't treat it like reality. Don't react. It's a reactionary position. You end up in a reactionary position. I just sit on my hands, work through it until the camera lens comes back into proper focus.
44:54
Speaker 1
Can you give yourself breathing exercises or the things you do?
44:57
Speaker 2
Yeah, box breathing. Somebody taught me that. My partner is aware of this, and it's always in that relationship where this comes out. And we're going to try as a couple to do it differently.
45:12
Speaker 1
So tell me about Gone.
45:15
Speaker 2
I think Gone is one of my favorite songs on the record. I think it's about loss, but it's about hope. That all those who've passed through our life that we truly, truly love, that love is still very real inside us. And it conjures the spirit of those people, and they're alive inside us. And I think that singing in a poetic way about that, it's that paradox again. It conjures my friends, and I love it. And I am very aware that when I sing it and people don't know it and I hit that line, it's going to be a stunner for some folks.
45:57
Speaker 1
What's the line that stuns you?
45:58
Speaker 2
It's been a year now. You've been gone. Yeah. Some people are like, whoa. They haven't had it handed to them that way. And that can be hard. And yet they thank me. Because I think, again, back to the beginning of our conversation, there's relief in knowing that somebody understands how you feel.
46:20
Speaker 1
Now that I'm thinking about it, you've been such a great songwriter about relationships, often about the failure of relationships. There's really only one of those on this album, which is the first song, which is Alcohol and Adderall. It's a song about a relationship coming apart and the memories that are left with it. But the rest of the album is very much, it's more about life passing and death and about a different part of your life.
46:50
Speaker 2
Yeah, yeah. You know, there is not a lot of that type of stuff. And it's probably because I'm not going through, I've been in, an extraordinary relationship going on nine years now, which for me is a world record.
47:05
Speaker 1
And I am so grateful. You're going to be on the page with the guy with the long fingernails in the Guinness record book. Nine years. Wow.
47:15
Speaker 2
My whole life has been three years and out, three years and out. And I'm so grateful that, uh, my sense of just getting started is still very alive with, with, uh, Jamie. And, um, Alcohol and Adderall is a reflection on loving an addict. In so many of my songs and in so much of my life, I've been the addict. I'm the one with the monkey on my back. I'm the one who's dealing with addiction and alcoholism. And this is a flipping of the viewpoint of now I'm the one, or my narrator really, is the one loving someone who's going down. And that is a hard place to be. You're just as powerless over drugs and alcohol as they are. That song, I think, was a flashback in a way. When that first line hit, I used to love a girl who danced for money. I loved it when that came out of my mouth.
48:11
Speaker 1
That's an amazing first line.
48:12
Speaker 2
Yeah, I loved it when it came out of my mouth because that goes, bang, Mary's 17 years old again. It goes back to that song, Evangeline, on my very first record. The dancer. The dancer has reappeared in another form now as an older woman.
48:29
Speaker 1
So many of your love songs, sometimes your unrequited love songs, are almost a form of addiction. They're people trying to let go. Oh, yeah. Maybe most powerfully with When a Woman Grows Cold, which is just a killer.
48:45
Speaker 2
Oh, yeah. Thank you. So much of the, I guess, story for me has been about addictions. Put down drugs, put down alcohol, and bang, almost immediately, sex and love, codependency, just out of control. And I didn't know that that was an addiction until it made itself absolutely clear that this is not normal, and you're behaving like a lunatic. And whatever's going on inside of you, you need help. And so you know, I found my way into the helping hands of a therapist, and I went to a treatment center for it, and I got into recovery from that side of the illness, you know. I'm an addict, and I am addicted to addicts. And that is just I think inevitable with a story like mine. You know, Bessel, who we referenced here earlier, Dr. van der Kolk, he always said that childhood trauma is the cause of addiction, period. And I think it's the cause of, for me, of addiction to addicts as well, codependency. So I've had to learn an awful lot in this life, and I'm still a student. But I think that music and song for me has been a great way of working through things and making sense of things and, you know, receiving light bulb moments of understanding that allow me different choices.
50:16
Speaker 1
I mean, Black Ice is a strange companion piece to When a Woman Grows Cold because you're the woman in that case.
50:25
Speaker 2
Yeah.
50:26
Speaker 1
Growing cold. You didn't know that. You always put yourself in the situation of the one who's imploring and then In this one.
50:34
Speaker 2
It's... That's a brilliant insight.
50:36
Speaker 1
You're the object.
50:37
Speaker 2
I think you're exactly right.
50:39
Speaker 1
Yeah.
50:40
Speaker 2
Yeah. And I didn't know it.
50:41
Speaker 1
I'm a sucker for train songs and you end on a beautiful train song. Tell me about that song.
50:46
Speaker 2
Tom Mason wrote that song. And Tom....
50:50
Speaker 1
It wasn't a co-write with you?
50:52
Speaker 2
No, he wrote that. I heard it played at Americana Music Festival 20 years ago or something. I was Going from club to club in Nashville, just taking in songwriters I hadn't heard before, I didn't know. Just no agenda, wandering around. You can stumble on some great stuff. And I heard this guy from Australia play this song. And when it was done, I introduced myself to him. And I got to know him over time. He's just a lovely guy. He died about two years ago, I guess now. But I told him, Tom, that's a perfect song. And if I can find a place for it, one day I'm going to record it. And I found a place for it. And I got to stick to my promise to him. This song, I think, is the right ender for this collection of songs.
51:47
Speaker 1
I thought so, too. Why did you think that?
51:49
Speaker 2
Because of hope.
51:50
Speaker 1
I'm interested why trains represent that. We're in such a modern society now. We've got a million other technological things, somehow, even more than a plane, anything else, the sound of a train is still so resonant with us.
52:08
Speaker 2
It's in our genetics. I mean, I think, I think that it's just a perfect metaphor for, hell, you can make it mean anything. It's such a malleable metaphor. Um, but there is a romance to trains. And I think, uh, bringing the train in is carrying a load of possibilities. And we can, from wherever we are in our life, fill in the blank as to what those possibilities are.
52:40
Speaker 1
It was also the way people told time for a long time before they had watches.
52:44
Speaker 2
Yeah, they knew the train would come at a certain time, right?
52:46
Speaker 1
They knew the train.
52:47
Speaker 2
Hear it coming.
52:47
Speaker 1
Yeah, and for Johnny Cash, it reminded him of the time that He was spending in prison. When I was listening, I thought, man, we still love trains. Doesn't matter what else comes.
53:00
Speaker 2
You know, Todd Snyder, play a train song. There is just something to trains and songwriters. We're going to be fixated on trains, I think, for the foreseeable future. There's just something, especially folk singers and country singers. Yeah.
53:13
Speaker 1
So what's next for you? You finish the album.
53:15
Speaker 2
Mm-hmm.
53:16
Speaker 1
And what happens?
53:17
Speaker 2
Well, now we hit the road. Go town to town to town to town all over the world and sing these songs for folks. Mm-hmm.
53:24
Speaker 1
Does this mean you're– are you traveling by bus or van?
53:26
Speaker 2
I've never traveled by bus.
53:28
Speaker 1
You've never– the bus is the– that's the key, isn't it?
53:32
Speaker 2
Never made enough money to travel by bus.
53:34
Speaker 1
Okay.
53:34
Speaker 2
I'm a solo artist. I kind of keep it– well, it has kept me. Or I keep it– I don't know. I've pondered that sometimes. What is it that would make it possible for me to grow the audience and have a bus? And then I thought almost immediately, you don't want to do that. You don't want a band. You don't want a tour manager. You don't want all these people that you have to pay that is going to create this urgency around having to do something. I don't want to have to do anything. So, you know, hop on a plane, go to Hertz, go to Enterprise, grab a car, and go town to town to town, drop the car off, fly home. That's my life. I never had a bus. And I probably, you know, won't unless some weird thing happens.
54:23
Speaker 1
Will these songs change as you perform them on stage?
54:26
Speaker 2
They're going to pretty much stay the way they are, I think. Guitar, harmonica, vocals with Jamie playing rhythm guitar and some lead spots and singing harmony.
54:39
Speaker 1
People from the album, though, it'll be so immediate for people because that's the sound of the album, too.
54:47
Speaker 2
See, that's appealing to me.
54:49
Speaker 1
Yeah.
54:50
Speaker 2
I can't recreate a band album with a duo. No. But with this one, I can play it as is, under spotlight, and that's going to just be true to what the record sounds like. So that's exciting for me.
55:02
Speaker 1
Well, it's another great album.
55:04
Speaker 2
Thank you.
55:04
Speaker 1
And I'll say it again, by the best songwriter working today.
55:07
Speaker 2
Ah, you're an angel. Thank you.
55:09
Speaker 1
Thank you so much for coming in.
55:10
Speaker 2
It's a pleasure and a privilege.
55:12
Speaker 1
Always a pleasure. Thank you, Mary. Broken Record is produced and edited by Leah Rose, with marketing help from Eric Sandler and Jordan McMillan. Our engineer is Ben Talladay. Our theme music's by Kenny Beats. I'm Justin Richman.
In addition to being a podcast host, Frederick Jay “Rick” Rubin is an American record producer and former co-president of Columbia Records. Along with Russell Simmons, he is the co-founder…
Malcolm Gladwell is co-founder of Pushkin Industries and host of the hit podcast Revisionist History. He is a journalist, a speaker, and the author of several New York Times bestsellers including The Tipping…
Justin Richmond is producer and co-host of the music podcast Broken Record with writer Malcolm Gladwell, New York Times editor Bruce Headlam, and music producer—and Def Jam co-founder—Rick Rubin. Justin…
Bruce Headlam is one of the co-creators of the music podcast Broken Record. He worked at The New York Times for 19 years, including two years running the 50-person Video…
Leah Rose is a senior producer and hosts episodes of Broken Record. A former music editor at XXL Magazine, she also served as an on-air personality for Eminem’s SiriusXM channel, Shade 45.…