Tim Harford
Tim Harford’s long-running column in the Financial Times, “The Undercover Economist,” reveals the economic ideas behind everyday experiences. His first book, The Undercover Economist, was published in 30 languages and sold…
Gain access to ad-free versions of 20+ podcasts from the Pushkin library along with exclusive bonus episodes and other member benefits.
Vasa was supposed to be the jewel of Sweden’s navy. King Gustav Adolph commissioned the mighty warship in 1625, as a symbol of his bold military ambitions. Vasa would go down in history for her astonishing maiden voyage, though not in the way anyone had hoped.
For a list of sources, see the show notes at timharford.com
Pushkin. Philip couldn't see much, but he must have felt trouble. He stood at the whipstaff, the long wooden lever that controlled the rudder. The rudder, in turn, steered the mightiest ship in the world, the great Swedish warship Vossa. It was a magnificent-looking vessel, no doubt about it, covered in ornate carvings and towering more than 170 feet from the bottom of the keel to the top of the main mast. Although we'll never know exactly what Philip knew and when he knew it, it seems very likely that every experienced sailor on Vossa knew that something wasn't right with the ship. Above the lapping of the waves and the creaking of the hemp rigging Philip would have heard Captain Surfering Hansen instructing the master gunner to prepare the salute. It was, after all, Vossa's first voyage, from the wharf in front of the royal palace itself out through the intricate channels of Stockholm's archipelago to the summer fleet base. It was a fine August day in 1628. Stockholm was home to about 15,000 people, and it seemed that half of them had come to stand on the harbour walls or surrounding slopes and watch the pride of the Swedish Navy show what she could do. Master Gunner, the salute. Vossa was engulfed in gun smoke. For a time, the cloud hung thick in the still air around the ship, only the masts peaking high above the sulphurous fumes. Then the smoke gradually dispersed, leaving Vossa floating aimlessly in the gentle current of Stockholm's harbour. Those on the shore could again see those on the ship, not only the old hands but new recruits, even wives and children who'd come aboard for the first few miles of Vossa's maiden voyage. Then came the order to raise the great white sails. Up they went, slowly and stubbornly, since there was barely a breath of wind to pull them into position. They hung limp above Philip's head. Vossa kept drifting at the same pace as the current, and with no flow across the rudder, Philip could push and heave on the whipstaff all he wanted. Vossa wouldn't answer to him unless the sails filled with wind. And then a gentle breeze briefly filled the topsail. Vossa began to move forward and to heel alarmingly to the side. The oak hull groaned. The pine decks tilted. The gunports, wide open, dipped to kiss the unforgivingly cold water. And then the breeze died. The ship pulled back from that flirtation with the sea, and slowly, so, so slowly, she hauled herself upright again. Some of the passengers laughed in embarrassment. They'd been alarmed by the movement, but there was no need to worry. They were just being silly. The ship's old hands weren't laughing. I'm Tim Harford, and you're listening... to cautionary tales. King Gustav II of Sweden Gustav Adolf, was not a man to be trifled with. In 1611, he'd come to the throne as a teenager in the middle of three wars against three of the great powers bordering the Baltic Sea, Russia, Denmark-Norway, and Poland-Lithuania. Gustav's cousin, the King of Poland, had once been King of Sweden, and made no secret of his desire to get the title back. But Gustav Adolf didn't mess around. Under his rule, Sweden took control of every Russian port on the Baltic Sea, captured the city of Riga from the Poles and built the most feared army in Europe. Greater Sweden was vast but rural. Even Stockholm was little more than a town. And yet the Swedish state was so well organised and so ruthlessly dedicated to military adventures that it could bully far larger opponents. Gustav was destined one day to march across Germany and conquer Munich 450 miles inland. But that was later. For now, Gustave wanted to bolster his already formidable navy. His sea captains commanded 30 warships, typically with a deck full of 12-pound cannons, that is, guns capable of firing a cannonball that weighs 12 pounds. Gustave wanted something on a different scale, warships built with a second gun deck and loaded with 24-pound guns. The standard naval measure of sheer firepower was the broadside. How much metal would be flying through the air if every gun on one side of the ship fired at the same time? Gustav's new warships would have a broadside of 800 pounds. That was more than twice what the largest ships in Europe could manage at the time. King Gustav Adolf commissioned two of these towering vessels, Vossa, named after the royal house of Sweden, and Eplet, meaning simply the apple, as well as two smaller ships. He wanted all four ships built and armed, and he wanted it to happen immediately. It was a daunting task for the shipwright, Master Henrik Hebertson, Hebertson had 20 years of shipbuilding experience, possibly more, and under his direction were 300 craftsmen in the navy shipyard, just a few hundred yards across the harbour from the walls of the royal palace itself. On paper, Master Hebertson was in a powerful position. The contract that Hebertson had agreed with the king gave him control of the royal shipyards in Stockholm, several nearby ironworks, exemption from various import tariffs, the right to cut timber from the royal forests, and regular cash payments. His wife and his brother helped to run the business, sourcing sailcloth and rope from Amsterdam and Lubeck, hemp from Danzig, and timber, iron and tar from across Sweden. And he had a capable deputy, overseeing the day-to-day workings of the Navy Yard. But the shadow of Gustav Adolf was not a comfortable place to be working. Sweden was suffering from inflation. which meant that the fixed price the Hebertsons had agreed with the king quickly looked like a loss-making proposition. The carpenters went on strike, insisting on being paid in silver rather than debased copper coins. When Hebertson's brother resold some royal timber to cope with the cash flow problem, the Swedish authorities investigated him for embezzlement. But the real problem was pressure from the hard-charging King Gustav Adolf. When the Swedish navy lost ten ships in a storm, for example, the king wanted some replacements built as quickly as possible, and added two medium-sized ships to his order. This was a rush job, to be completed before Vossa and Eplert and the smaller ships. Master Hebertson had already selected trees of the perfect size and shape and cut the timbers. Starting again on these new different ships would cost time and yet more money. Increasingly tense letters passed back and forth between the navy shipyard in Stockholm and King Gustav, who was fighting a war in Poland. Eventually, Gustav Adolf backed down. According to the author of the definitive book Vasa, the historian Fred Hocker, for Gustav to concede in a disagreement was almost unheard of. Smoke belched from the forges of the anchor smithy. The sawyers turned great logs of oak and pine into planks for the hull on the decks, while the carpenters gradually assembled those planks into the hulls, first of Vossa and then of Epplet. But Hebertson was still far from happy. The king wanted so many guns on the ship, heavy bronze cannons, two decks of them. Would the upper decks even take the weight? Hebertson was nervous. He was also not well. He hadn't been well for months. As the navy shipyard bustled and the ribs of Vossa started to rise above the dock like the carcass of some great leviathan, Henrik Hebertson took to his bed. and died. Vossa was launched in the spring of 1627, not long after her designer had passed away. But there was plenty of work for the Navy Yard to do on her yet. Under the supervision of Master Henrik's capable deputy, Hein Jakobsen, the floating hull needed to be fitted out with decks and decoration, and the masts to be rigged. Jakobsen wasn't happy. The ship was so tall, the upper decks so heavy. Even before the guns were installed, would she really stay upright? He'd done his best, widening the hull as far as he could without taking the ship apart and starting again. It wasn't until the spring of 1628 that Vossa was carefully towed around the harbour until reaching her new mooring outside the royal palace. There, the guns would be fitted, provisions put on board, and finally, finally, the new flagship might sail to Poland to join the impatient King Gustav Adolf. By the summer, Vossa was ready to set sail, But Captain Surfering Hansen and his officers were no less uneasy than Jakobsen had been. The design was so ambitious, almost unprecedented. Was it safe? Captain Hansen asked the man in charge of commissioning King Gustav's navy, Vice Admiral Fleming, to come to the dock and take a look. Hansen had organised a standard stability test. Thirty men stood on deck. They'd rush to one side of the ship, then to the other, then back again, and again, and again, trying to rock her back and forth. Normally, such a test might see the men running across deck 20 times, but after just three, the ship was lurching so alarmingly that Admiral Fleming gave orders to stop. Slowly, slowly, the ship stopped rocking and returned to its graceful upright posture beside the dock. Fleming shook his head as he contemplated their predicament. I wish His Majesty were home, said Admiral Fleming, but His Majesty was in Poland, and he was waiting impatiently for his new flagship to join him. Cautionary Tales will be back after the break. August the 10th, 1628. A fine, warm day. Barely any wind. Captain Surfering Hansen gave the order, and the mooring lines were released. In front of the royal palace and thousands of townsfolk, the stern of Vossa swung out into the harbour. The ship, all 1,200 tonnes of it, would be pulled by hand along the quayside, until she reached the tip of the old town, where the sails could finally be raised. There were at least 150 people on board, maybe 200. The ship was almost a floating cathedral, the high masts like a church spire, the vast, lavish carvings on the stern resembling a great church organ. Indeed, the work had been led by an organ sculptor. Vossa towered high above the spectators. although the gun ports themselves were not so very far above the water. It was a breathtaking sight. But that was not why Captain Hansen was holding his breath. The ship crept down the side of the island until she could creep no further and needed to set out under her own power. The current flowing from the great Lake Malern pushed the ship out into the harbour, where she drifted slowly east, sails empty. The spectacle of the 64-gun salute did little to banish the sense of helplessness. Surfing Hansen had his eye on the cliffs at Tegel Viken, less than a mile to the east. There was a gap in the cliffs there. and any experienced Swedish sailor knew that the wind would often gust through. Vossa crept closer and closer, and as she passed the gap, the wind filled her sails, and she began to lean towards the water again. The captain could tell, all the old hands could tell, that this time there was no way she would right herself. There was no stiffness in the ship. no resistance to the rolling movement. She just kept leaning, like a drunkard too disoriented to find her balance. Captain Hansen shouted orders to drop the sails, pull in the guns and close the ports. One of the VIP guests, Vice Admiral Erik Jørnsson, was an experienced artillery master. He'd already dashed below decks to ensure the cannons were secure. If one of them broke loose and slid to the wrong side of the ship, all would be lost. But both Hansen and Jönsson knew, deep down, that all was lost anyway. Helm hard to leeward, bellowed the captain. Philip heaved at the whipstaff, turning the ship toward the breeze to take the wind out of her sails. All too late. As the ship kept rolling... The open ports dipped into the water and started drinking deeply. The cold water of the harbour started to fill the belly of the ship, weighing her down and pulling her yet further over. The passengers began to scream, scrambling to the starboard side of the ship, which was higher above the water. Below the decks, some of the crew tried to mount the ladders, a hard task at such a crazy angle. The cannons tugged at their moorings as the water rose around them. Jönsson' s barked orders were suddenly cut dead. The artillery master had been struck by flying debris. His body sprawled motionless on the deck. In the steerage, Philip stayed at his post, straining at the whipstaff with all his strength. On the quarterday, high up at the back of the ship, Captain Hansen could see the catastrophe unfolding with terrible clarity. The ship had two rowing boats attached, but both had been dragged under. No chance for escape there. The passengers were helpless with panic. The crew? All too many of them were still below decks. Hull filling with water, the ship was now sinking straight into the cold darkness of the harbour. The air was bubbling furiously out of every hatch, the deck itself awash. It had been less than ten minutes since the gust had caught the sails. The captain climbed over the railings of the high quarterdeck, finding it easier to keep his balance standing on the hull and on the deck. He yelled for everybody to keep clear of the rigging, Glancing around, he could see the little flotilla of boats carrying spectators. That was some cause for hope. And the shore wasn't far away either. Good news for those who could swim. Vossa was now almost completely submerged. Captain Hansen waited until the last moment before he leaped into the water and felt his woolen jacket start to drag him down, down. He kicked for the surface, and soon strong hands grabbed him and pulled him into a rowing boat. He looked around. On the shore, dozens of survivors sat dazed and shivering despite the afternoon sunshine. Others were, like him, being hauled into rescue boats. Still others were clinging to the rigging above the waterline. Vossa's hull had settled on the bottom, and her masts poked above the surface. but around 30 people were dragged down and stayed down, never to breathe the air again. When Captain Hansen could see that there was no more to be done, he gave orders to be rowed the short distance back to the royal palace. He would have some explaining to do. Ever since I first heard about the Vossa disaster, I've been fascinated Why did it sink? What can we learn? That's the cautionary tale's philosophy, of course, but it's important to learn the right lesson. Here's one idea. In the year 2001, In the business school journal Academy of Management Executive, three business school academics published an article titled Vossa Syndrome, Insights from a 17th Century New Product Disaster. The bottom line? Vossa was sunk by what the academics described as an overly ambitious product development process. If only Master Henrik had used a particular management decision matrix, he would have figured out that the quality King Gustav Adolf really desired Vossa to have was not the impressive appearance, nor even the firepower, but that the ship stayed afloat. Well, OK, good to know. But I'm not sure this is particularly helpful... I think Master Henrik knew that King Gustav Adolf preferred his flagship not to immediately roll over and sink, even if he wasn't using the management tools advocated by the business school professors. The real lesson seems like basic common sense, and for many years it was the consensus in Sweden about why Vossa sank. It sank because Gustav Adolf meddled with the design. micromanaging details about which he had no knowledge. He kept changing the specifications, and most damagingly, gave orders at the last minute to install the second gun deck, meaning that Master Henrik suddenly had to fit a much taller, heavier superstructure on a hull that was already built. The story was repeated in books and TV shows, King Gustav Adolf was an autocratic boss who didn't know what he didn't know about maritime engineering. Our museum perpetuated it for about 20 years, says Fred Hocker, who, as well as being the author of Vossa, is the head of research at the Vossa Museum. Virtually everyone accepted this story without questioning whether there was any actual evidence to support it. And that's the problem. There is no evidence to support the tale of the meddling king. It's a myth. But when a story sounds right, people often don't ask too many questions, especially when everyone involved has been dead for centuries and thus unlikely to argue. It's true that Gustave put a great deal of pressure on the shipbuilders. But what's not true is that the king ordered major changes to Vossa partway through construction, and it's also not true that he added the second gun deck late in the day. Writes Fred Hocker, the order for the ship's armament in the summer of 1626, that's two years before she set sail, is clearly intended for a large ship with at least two full gun decks, and had to have been made before the construction of the hull was very far advanced. King Gustav Adolf was a hard man to please, but he didn't meddle with the ship's design after it had been agreed. Drawing lessons from history is all very well, but let's not draw the wrong ones. So if we can't look to regal micromanagement or the inadvertent comedy of a theory that suggests maybe people didn't realise the king wanted his flagship to float, then why did Vossa sink? As Captain Hansen was rowed towards the royal palace, you can bet that he was thinking of little else. Cautionary tales will return after the break. If Captain Surfering Hansen had been a bit wiser, he would never have sailed with the gun ports open. But Hansen's mistake was a blessing in disguise. Sooner or later, Vossa was going to roll over and sink. And if the captain had somehow managed to nurse her out of the Stockholm archipelago and across the Baltic Sea to Poland, she would have rolled over and sunk mid-battle, in deep water, and with a full complement of soldiers. Instead of 30 people drowning, the death toll could easily have been more than 400. Not that Captain Hansen planned to use this as a defence. The king was, of course, furious, and in a blistering letter from the front in Poland, he ordered his council to find out who was responsible. The council hadn't waited for the letter, they'd already set up a tribunal to carry out an inquest. So, Had Captain Hansen been drunk? Not at all, he swore. Another officer, under questioning, stiffly admitted that he had taken communion. Had the guns rolled loose? No. Incredibly, Vice Admiral Erik Jørnsson, badly injured as the ship rolled, had survived the disaster, his battered body carried to safety by fellow sailors. After days near death, he'd recovered sufficiently to give testimony. He assured the tribunal that every gun on Vossa was secure. And he'd gone below decks, fully expecting not to return. For Jørnsson claimed the ship was so unstable, nothing would have prevented it from rolling over. What about the ballast, the stones placed at the lowest point of the hull to keep the ship's centre of gravity low? The master in charge of the ballast pointed out that he had stood in the hold and supervised the placing of every stone. The ballast was properly stowed and there was not room for one stone more. But was there enough ballast to keep the ship from being top-heavy? The master explained, if he'd added even more, the gun ports would have been too close to the water and the ship would have sunk anyway. The master shipwright, Hein Jakobsen, was summoned before the tribunal, but he had a cast iron defence. Master Henrik had agreed a design with the king and then died. Hein Jakobsen had simply finished the job. He had built the ship that the king had approved. In the end, the inquiry reached a convenient conclusion. Henrik Hebertson's design had been bad, but he was dead. Nobody else had done anything wrong. In fact, they could all be promoted. It's not an outrageous verdict. Henrik Hebertson was Dutch, and while the Dutch made the best ships in the world, they did build them for shallow waters. Hebertson had made Voss's hull shallow, even though in the Baltic Sea it could have been deeper. And because he was worried about the weight of all those massive guns, Hebertson had made the gun decks from massive beams of oak to support the weight. That was overkill. Actually, Vossa's guns were a new design with a shorter barrel. They packed heavy cannonballs, but they weighed a fair bit less than their predecessors. Unfortunately, nobody seems to have told Master Henrik that. and he died before the guns were delivered. As a result, Vossa's upper decks were too heavy, heavier than they needed to be, and her hull was too shallow, shallower than it needed to be. The result was a ship that was begging to roll over and sink at the first opportunity. And she did. But that's not quite the end of the story. Let's go back to that crucial moment when Vice Admiral Fleming and Captain Surfering Hansen stood in front of the palace watching 30 sailors run back and forth on the deck of Vossa. Both of them could see immediately that the ship wasn't seaworthy. So why did they decide to go to sea? Early in the 1990s, a young researcher named Amy Edmondson looked at evidence from medical teams at two Massachusetts hospitals and was bewildered by what she found. Her hypothesis had been that the best teams make the fewest mistakes. The data told a different story. The teams who displayed the best teamwork were the ones making the most mistakes. What was going on? It took a while, but eventually Edmondson solved the puzzle. The best teams didn't make more errors. they admitted to more errors. Dysfunctional teams admitted to very few, for the simple reason that nobody on those teams felt safe pointing out problems. Edmondson has spent the following three decades studying mistakes, and she's best known for popularizing the term psychological safety. Some organizations promote psychological safety. They're the ones where people feel that it's okay to speak up if they see a problem, and where the mistakes of the past are constructively discussed with a view to preventing the mistakes of the future. I like to think of cautionary tales as a psychologically safe space. But psychological safety doesn't happen by accident. You need to work for it. Edmondson tells the story of Paul O'Neill, who became the boss of the US aluminium company Alcoa in 1987. He set the apparently unachievable target of zero workplace injuries and wrote to every worker in the company, giving them his home phone number and asking them to call him if there were any safety violations. That's how to communicate to workers. that you need to hear the truth. King Gustav Adolf didn't have a home phone number. Instead, he did have a fearsome reputation. Yes, Vossa sank because the design was too big a leap from what had been attempted before. She sank because the shipwright was too nervous about the strength of the gun decks, while accepting without question the notion that all ships need to have a shallow draft. and she sank because the captain set sail with the gun ports open and the wind blowing from the south through the gap in the cliffs. But most fundamentally, Vossa sank because Vice Admiral Fleming could see the ship was bad, but couldn't summon up the courage to tell King Gustav. Fleming corresponded regularly with the king, says historian Fred Hocker. but did not mention anything about the ship's problems in his letters after the demonstration. Meanwhile, every letter from the king to Fleming brought fresh pressure to get the ship into combat. Vossa was literally docked at the gates of Gustav's palace. If the king had been home, he would have seen the ship's instability firsthand and ordered her to be rebuilt. But Fleming refused. couldn't bear to be the man to tell Gustav what he needed to hear. Instead, Fleming kept his mouth shut and hoped for the best. The story of Vossa has one final chapter. The ship's wreck was relocated by a team of divers in the 1950s. The team explored the wreck, planning to lift her back to the surface... But before they did, they found 15 more or less complete skeletons, nameless victims of the disaster. They were labelled A, B, C and so on, before being given names. The skeleton of victim F was lying right next to the whipstaff. A strange place to drown, unless it had been the helmsman, loyally following his captain's orders to steer into the wind. until he drowned at his post. Not knowing the name of Sailor F, archaeologists dubbed him Philip. Vasa was painstakingly restored over the next three decades. Stockholm harbour is cold, oxygen poor and a mixture of salt and fresh water. Most of the things that might eat wood don't thrive in such conditions, so Vasa is astonishingly well preserved. In 1988, she was moved into a permanent museum on the waterfront. It's well worth a visit. Vossa is utterly spectacular. As Fred Hocker of the Vossa Museum jokes, it was the world's least successful warship, and now it's the world's most successful maritime museum. If you could stand on the roof of the museum, you'd see the full scope of the ship's travels. From the site of the shipyard, to the palace dock, to the waters where she sank less than a mile away. The museum is a monument to human ingenuity. It's also a reminder of how much trouble and tragedy could have been forestalled if Vice Admiral Fleming had been brave enough to tell the king the bad news, or if the king had made it clear that bravery was not a prerequisite for for telling him the truth. This episode was inspired by the Vossa Museum and by Fred Hocker's beautiful book Vossa. For a full list of our sources see the show notes at timharford.com Cautionary Tales is written by me, Tim Harford with Andrew Wright Alice Fiennes and Ryan Dilley. It's produced by Georgia Mills and Marilyn Rust. The sound design and original music are the work of Pascal Wise. Ben-Nadav Hafri edited the scripts. The show also wouldn't have been possible without the work of Jacob Weisberg, Greta Cohn, Corinne Gileard-Fisher, Eric Sandler, Christina Sullivan, Keira Posey and Owen Miller. Cautionary Tales is a production of Pushkin Industries. If you like the show, please remember to share, rate and review. It really does make a difference to us. And if you want to hear it ad-free and receive a bonus audio episode, video episode and members-only newsletter every month, why not join the Cautionary Club? To sign up, head to patreon.com slash cautionaryclub. That's patreon, p-a-t-r-e-o-n dot com slash cautionaryclub.
Tim Harford’s long-running column in the Financial Times, “The Undercover Economist,” reveals the economic ideas behind everyday experiences. His first book, The Undercover Economist, was published in 30 languages and sold…