Lucy Sherriff
Lucy Sherriff, host of the podcast Gone, is a journalist with 12 years of experience covering human rights, gender and news across the world. She has reported from countries such…
Subscribe to Pushkin+ now to binge the entire season ad-free. You'll also receive access to exclusive benefits from more than 20 podcasts in the Pushkin network.
On a hiking trip to climb Mount of the Holy Cross, Michelle Vanek, a 35-year-old mother of four, suddenly vanished. For nearly two decades, her family and the community searched for answers – until, in 2022, when there was a new lead… and a strange dream.
A member of the local mountain rescue group, Pastor Scott Beebe, tells Lucy how everything unfolded.
For more on this story:
Pushkin. Lucy here. Before we get into this episode, I wanted to let you know that you can hear all episodes from Gone The Disappearances ad-free right now by signing up for Pushkin +. We're only able to continue doing our research and reporting on these stories with the help of you, our listeners, and we appreciate your support so much. With a Pushkin Plus subscription, you'll also get ad-free listening from all Pushkin shows, plus other series binges, full audiobooks, and more. Find Pushkin Plus on the Gone show page on Apple Podcasts or at pushkin.fm slash plus. Deep in Colorado's White River National Forest, near the popular ski resort town of Vail, there exists a mountain, which for decades has drawn hikers, skiers, and holy men alike to its peak. And this particular peak is iconic, special, because for most of the year, a cross of snow appears on its northeastern face, visible for miles around, giving this craggy pinnacle a portentous name, Mount of the Holy Cross.
01:21
Speaker 2
It has held a fascination for people for, you know, decades. And hundreds of people every summer go up and summit the mountain, and some even like to ski down it. And it is... It is not for the faint of heart.
01:39
Speaker 1
Scott Beebe is a Lutheran pastor. He's also an avid hiker. He's been up the mountain many times, and he remembers the first time he saw that snowy cross.
01:50
Speaker 2
You can't see it from the parking, you know, the trailhead. You have to hike up Half Moon Pass, and then you take this turn around the pass, and there it is. And it is, it's incredible.
02:03
Speaker 1
The mountain holds another draw for hikers. It's one of 58 mountains in Colorado with an elevation of over 14,000 feet. They're dubbed the Fourteeners. They're famously challenging mountains known for their steep terrain. And back in September of 2005, Michelle Vanik, a 35-year-old mother of four, was looking for a challenge.
02:28
Speaker 2
Her neighbor had hiked mountains. I think about half of the 14ers had said, hey, I'm going up Mount of the Holy Cross, do you want to come with? Michelle had been a triathlete, but she had just given birth to her fourth child, and she was really looking to get back in shape and saw this as a wonderful opportunity to get out and hike and see something new and go exploring in the mountains.
02:55
Speaker 1
Michelle and her hiking partner made a plan. Early one morning... They set off for the mountain. Several hours later, her partner returned, alone. Michelle had vanished. For years, her disappearance haunted the community.
03:15
Speaker 2
She was the first person to go missing on the mountain that we were not able to locate and bring back.
03:22
Speaker 1
And Michelle's family was left with nothing but unanswered questions. There was speculation, conspiracy theories. but no trace of what had happened to her. Until a new lead nearly two decades later. And a strange dream. I'm Lucy Sheriff, and this is Gone, The Disappearances, a series where we go beyond the news headlines of people who have gone missing.
03:53
Speaker 2
Still no sign of 35-year-old Michelle Vanik of Lakewood. A mother of four, she's been missing in the backcountry near Vail since Saturday.
04:00
Speaker 1
The two were separated near the summit, they thought, just for a little while. Michelle was never seen again. The search for missing hiker Michelle Vanek has been suspended. A recent discovery changing our understanding of a mystery that has lingered in Colorado for nearly two decades.
04:16
Speaker 2
The search for this woman, Michelle Vanek, may be over.
04:31
Speaker 1
Scott Beebe is easygoing but meticulous. When we spoke, he came armed with years of notes and news clippings. He's also energetic, which suits his extracurricular activities. In addition to being a pastor, he's a member of the Vail Mountain Rescue Group, which pretty much does what it says on the tin.
04:51
Speaker 2
So Vail Mountain Rescue is made up entirely of volunteers, as are all mountain rescue teams across the country.
04:58
Speaker 1
And.
05:00
Speaker 2
You know, people think we're ski patrol. We're not ski patrol. We cover the whole county and we are on call 24 hours a day, seven days a week, 365. If somebody gets lost in the woods, if there's an accident, an avalanche, any kind of accident that requires medical assistance, people who are lost, we get the call from dispatch and we go and find them, bring them out.
05:28
Speaker 1
That's intense work. Do you have a record of how many people you've rescued?
05:31
Speaker 2
Our biggest year ever, we had 175 missions. Currently, we are the third busiest mountain rescue team in the country.
05:43
Speaker 1
Back in 2005, Scott was living south of Denver, a couple of hours from Vail. He didn't know Michelle Vanik, but he distinctly remembers when the news broke that she'd gone missing.
05:55
Speaker 2
I still have all the original newspaper articles. from her disappearance. It came out in the Rocky Mountain News and in the Denver Post.
06:04
Speaker 1
And what made you keep those articles?
06:07
Speaker 2
I hiked all the 14ers, and so anything that happens on one of those mountains, it's intriguing to me. And this one particularly, because there were news reports and articles for a whole week, and she disappeared so completely. That, I think, is what shocked people. They didn't find Not a boot print, not a gum wrapper, ski pole, nothing. Absolutely nothing. And nothing like that had ever happened before.
06:40
Speaker 1
According to news reports, Michelle had felt an itch to do something challenging after having her fourth child. She loved hiking, but her husband Ben didn't. And so she bonded with their close family friend and neighbor, Eric Sawyer, over their shared passion. She wanted to explore the high country. On the morning of September 24th, 2005, Michelle and Eric set off for the mountain.
07:08
Speaker 2
And the problem started right away. Her hiking partner, who had the map, couldn't locate the appropriate trailhead. And things just went downhill from there. I mean, he forgot lunch, and he was trying to navigate off of a very... what I would consider an inferior map. And by the time he realized where they actually were, it was either continue going or if they backtracked to take the appropriate trail, they wouldn't have had time to summit the peak. So, you know, he's looking on the map in the book and the book says, well, if we continue this way, it's just another route. A little bit longer, but just another route. And so that's what they chose to do.
07:57
Speaker 1
There are two trails that go up Mount of the Holy Cross. The plan was to hike the easier one, the North Ridge Trail. An innocent misdirection meant they ended up on a different trail, the Halo Ridge Trail, which was a little longer, by about four miles. But it was also substantially harder, with more peaks to climb.
08:19
Speaker 2
And by the time they got to the west face, where you climb up and actually get to the summit, Michelle said she was out of water, out of food, and she was, yeah, she was spent. She was spent. And so her hiking partner said, well, I'll tell you what, and it's only about 400 feet to the summit. He said, I really want to go to the summit. So I'm going to go up and tag the summit. You continue across the boulder field. And he pointed to a little hump kind of on the horizon. He said, go to that point. and start down and I will catch up with you. So he goes up to the top and he comes down and he was on the trail down to where he was supposed to meet her. But when he got to that point, she was not there. So he's up and down on the North Ridge calling her name, ran into some other hikers, asked them, could they please help him? Searched, I think it was maybe an hour, two hours. And no sign, no sign.
09:28
Speaker 1
Eventually, Eric called the sheriff's office, who called Vail Mountain Rescue. That night, they launched a rescue mission that would become Colorado's largest ever search for a missing hiker.
09:40
Speaker 2
There were over 850 people over the course of those eight days that went out searching. And the community turned out in force, hundreds and hundreds of people show up to help search and try and find her.
09:55
Speaker 1
It's so hard to just picture the vastness. I had to go and Google. search it just to get an idea of this terrain because I've never been to this area. And you think, okay, someone goes missing on a trail. You just look either side of the trail. But can you just explain briefly, you know, this is really harsh terrain. And it's just, it's massive. It's huge.
10:20
Speaker 2
It's miles of boulder field and in boulders, you know, some the size of cars.
10:27
Speaker 1
Wow.
10:27
Speaker 2
And here you are, you're looking around every boulder or if she had stepped on a rock and there was a rock slide and she was buried. And that was the, you know, as the search went on, the areas that people were searching started out wide and then they got narrower and narrower. And, you know, I mean, I can show you maps where they start with a large area and it's searching smaller, smaller, smaller. I mean, almost to the point where they're on hands and knees, you know, turning over rocks.
10:57
Speaker 1
There were helicopters, dog teams and countless volunteers, but no Michelle. To add to the difficulty, it began snowing heavily. Hopes of finding her alive were dwindling. On the eighth day, rescuers called off the search. But the Eagle County Sheriff's Office kept the investigation open. And the Colorado Bureau of Investigation launched a website asking for tips. And then they waited. In 2009, Scott and his family moved to Vail. As he got involved in the community and joined the Vail Mountain Rescue Group, he got to know Michelle's husband, Ben. In fact, he knew him. He became a kind of liaison between Ben, the rescue group, and the sheriff's office. At that point, Michelle had been missing for roughly four years, but her case remained on everyone's minds. It seemed less and less probable that she was alive, but there was still hope that they might locate her remains. The rescue group often talked about a well-known photo of Michelle, taken the day she went missing. In it, she poses mid-stride with her poles, smiling at the camera.
12:15
Speaker 2
And team members, you know, every time we would go back on the mountain to bring somebody down who maybe got injured or lost, we were always reminded by our mission coordinators, hey, you know, you're going to be out there. Michelle was wearing, you know, black pants, blue jacket, blue hat, just keep your eyes open. But for all these years, there was absolutely nothing.
12:39
Speaker 1
People don't do well with absolutely nothing. Which is maybe why speculation and conspiracy theories started to fill that vacuum. Everything from Michelle getting kidnapped to Eric, her hiking partner, being somehow involved. People couldn't help but wonder, what if Michelle hadn't simply wandered off the trail?
12:58
Speaker 2
There's always been this suspicion, right? From the very beginning, there was this suspicion that her hiking partner had done something, that there had been some kind of nefarious... He tried to kiss her and she rebuffed him and, you know, he pushed her off a cliff. I mean, all kinds or there, you know, that there were other hikers that, you know, may have encountered her and did something, you know, nefarious. People started to, you know, in the absence of fact, you fill in the blanks, right? And, you know, people made up what they think the narrative was. So when she disappeared, the rumor mill, it went crazy because we had nothing. Absolutely not a ski pole, not a gum wrapper, not a boot print, absolutely nothing. It's like she was, you know, sucked up into thin air.
13:57
Speaker 1
Investigators at the sheriff's office asked Eric if he had anything to do with Michelle's disappearance or if he'd harmed her. He said no to both. And to be clear, there's never been any evidence to suggest otherwise. He's also never been charged with anything. Meanwhile, Michelle's husband Ben and her four kids had to come to terms with the idea that they might never find Michelle's remains. And then, 17 years later, there was a breakthrough. In 2022, a local teacher named Rob Worrell and his son decided to go bouldering at Mount of the Holy Cross.
14:52
Speaker 2
And they like to get off what we call off-piste, off the main trails and explore. And so they had hiked up into an area called the Angelica Kular. No trails. It's all done by, you know, map and compass. And so they were walking through this kind of open area. It kind of looks like the Garden of Eden. It's, you know, huge boulders, trees, open meadow. And Rob and his son were hiking through the area to, you know, like I say, go bouldering. And they found this boot. And it was the lower part of a hiking boot, kind of leaning up against a rock. And the leather upper was all chewed off. But the bottom, the rand, the sole of the boot, was still intact. And it was a very distinct boot. had a leather upper and a two-tone rubber sole with a little tan plastic instep. And they find this boot sitting next to a rock in the middle of nowhere. I mean, there's no trails, just a bunch of rocks. And so they took a picture and they sent it to us.
16:02
Speaker 1
Us, meaning Vail Mountain Rescue. Scott was on the board at the time.
16:07
Speaker 2
And, you know, and I'm looking at it and I was able to compare the lower part of the boot from the pictures that they had to the last picture we have of Michelle as she is hiking. And it's the famous picture. She's in a blue jacket, black pants. She's got her hiking poles out and her mittens on. And if you look down at the boot, I think it's her right boot. You can see the little tan plastic instep of the boot.
16:39
Speaker 1
What was your reaction? Like you found a boot after this amount of time.
16:44
Speaker 2
It was like, oh my God. I'm in a place where no one was able to search initially because they didn't search until the last day, the eighth day. And by then there was two feet of snow.
16:54
Speaker 1
Right.
16:55
Speaker 2
So we, you know, we get the coordinates for where the boot is. I take a team up and we found the boot, did what we call a scuff search of the area, looking for bones, bones, backpack, any more equipment, anything like that. Didn't find anything else. Brought the boot down, turned it over to the sheriff's department. Forensics proved that it was hers.
17:24
Speaker 1
Vail Mountain Rescue decided to send a team of six up to the Angelica couloir, where the boot had been found, in the hopes that they would find Michelle's remains. But it was in the lead-up to this search that something odd happened. One evening before the search, Scott was talking to one of the team members. Her name was Heather, and she was the lone woman on the team of six.
17:48
Speaker 2
And we were chatting, and I said, I said, Heather, I said, you're going in with five guys. They're all type A, and they all like to be in control. So I said, promise me when you're in there, if you see something, say something, speak up. And she said, oh, Scott, she said, you know, I carried an M60 in Iraq. I can take care of myself. And we laughed. And then it just kind of popped in my head. I said, when you're up there, do me a favor. Put yourself in her shoes and ask yourself, if I were Michelle, what would I do? And, you know, I've got a wife and two daughters in their 20s. And I know that I don't think like they do and they don't think like I do. Right. And she said, OK, I can do that. Said, thank you. So that it was that night then I'm sleeping and I have a dream. And it was a woman's voice and the voice said, I don't want to be found by a guy. Guys, plural, got me into trouble. I don't want to be found by a guy. That's all it was. And I woke up and I sat up in bed and I looked at my clock. It was two o'clock in the morning. And I thought, what in God's holy name is that?
19:17
Speaker 1
Okay. I need to understand a bit more about your spirituality and your faith. Are you an Old Testament fire and brimstone kind of guy? Or are you like a Gnostic gospel, metaphysical miracles and, you know, former life?
19:33
Speaker 2
I'm a Lutheran pastor. I've been ordained for 40 years. We don't go into fancy, you know, cosmic spirits speaking in the wind, ghosts we're more cerebral right wrong or indifferent and every other Lutheran pastor would disagree with me but I've never had a vision all I knew is that the voice was hers and I don't want to be found by a guy Guy's got me into trouble. I don't want to be found by a guy.
20:13
Speaker 1
Very specific.
20:14
Speaker 2
And I thought, okay, what is this all about?
20:18
Speaker 1
Quick aside here. I used to live in LA and I'm all for visions and psychic stuff, as you might remember if you listened to our last season. So I was completely into Scott's dream. Who are these guys? Plural, this voice had mentioned. And even though Scott didn't quite know what to make of it, it nagged at him.
20:38
Speaker 2
And so I thought I had the file. her search file here at the, at my house, one of the advantages of being the president of the board. So I went, I pulled out the files and I started going through each day of the search to see how it was conducted, who, you know, who were the, the, the team leads and how, how did the search unfold? And what I found was it was all run by males and the females got, what I call the cookie and casserole assignments. The guys got flown up in the helicopters, right? They're doing.
21:18
Speaker 1
They got the Mission Impossible kind of.
21:21
Speaker 2
Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. And the gals are, you know, go down Fall Creek or here's 10 volunteers, just go and, you know, walk down a trail and just, you know, make sure none of them get hurt.
21:32
Speaker 1
Right.
21:34
Speaker 2
And I thought, I wonder if the women on the team, we had 17 at the time, I wonder if they would be willing to sit down and look through the box, go through each day's, you know, hiking profiles, all that stuff, and give it a second look.
21:51
Speaker 1
So you took this dream really seriously?
21:53
Speaker 2
Oh, yeah. I've never had anything like it before in my life.
21:56
Speaker 1
Did you tell anyone about it?
21:59
Speaker 2
Not for a while. The first people I told were two women, right? Megan and Emily, they're team leads on our mountain rescue team. I called him. I said, hey, I got this wild idea. Can I take you out for a cup of coffee and can we just talk?
22:14
Speaker 1
Yeah, sure.
22:14
Speaker 2
So we're sitting outside and I said, I had this dream. And, you know, went through the whole dream and they both look at each other and they go, well, yeah, that's called intuition. Women have that all the time. I said, well, I'm not a woman and I've never had anything like that happen in my life. So I said, would you be willing, I'm going to give you the file, the whole, everything we have. Would you look through the file, read the reports and tell me what you would do? I don't want any guys involved at all. And they said, yeah, sure. We can do that. 17 women. And they, they jumped on it.
22:59
Speaker 1
Wow. Was there any pushback to this? Like what, What were the male members? Like, wait a minute.
23:06
Speaker 2
I think the only reason this happened, there were some significant leaders on the team who wanted to put the kibosh on it. Thought this was crazy. It's dumb. We're not going to risk people. We're not going to do it. The only reason it happened is because I was president of the board and I got to pull rank. And I said, no, this is bigger than the team.
23:30
Speaker 1
The search for Michelle's remains would continue. and Scott's dream would be put into action. How that all unfolded in just a moment. To recap, after nearly two decades, there was finally a breakthrough in the search for Michelle Vanek. But though the search team successfully retrieved her boot... They found no sign of Michelle's remains. All they had was the boot and Scott's dream. After their meeting with Scott, the team leads of Veil Mountain Rescue pulled together an all-women search team who began working on a profile of Michelle and coming up with an entirely new plan. Scott's dream was front and centre.
24:25
Speaker 2
And so for their very first search... They were able to get a helicopter, one of the medical helicopters, to fly six of them up onto the North Ridge to do an initial search. They kind of narrowed down where they think Michelle may have gone. And they took it so seriously, they made sure that the pilot of the helicopter was a woman.
24:51
Speaker 1
That's amazing. In the fall of 2024, the team boarded the helicopter and headed towards a nearby ridge. But because of the wind that day, they were forced to land in a different spot, further away, and hike their way over.
25:06
Speaker 2
They dropped off at 6. At 6 o'clock in the morning, they don't get to the search area until 2.30 in the afternoon. And they're bushwhacking down and up. And so by the time they get to the ridge, they're all wiped out. And they're sitting up on the ridge. And the plan was to drop down into the couloir and do some searching. But they were all just hashed. And all of a sudden, Erica German says, I can feel her.
25:38
Speaker 1
Wow.
25:40
Speaker 2
She's around here somewhere. And one by one, all six of them said the same thing. They were all sensing her presence. And so they start looking around. And they're kind of looking over down into the cliff, down into the couloir. And they see three areas that they think, you know, if she had gotten off this ridge, she may have dropped down into one of these three areas.
26:07
Speaker 1
They noted the three areas and planned to return in a month. But one of the group, Erica German, couldn't let the feeling go. A few weeks later, she went back up with another member of Vail Mountain Rescue, Zachary Smith. who, yes, is a man, but that was okay because Erica was in charge.
26:27
Speaker 2
And they saw an area that had not been searched, and they thought, you know, let's go up there and see if we find anything. And by golly, they're searching. They look over a cliff face, and there's her backpack.
26:43
Speaker 1
Wow.
26:44
Speaker 2
And I was on the radio, you know, with the two of them. They radioed in. We have found a pack and it looks like the one she's wearing in the picture. And it was at the base of about a 30-foot cliff over the ridge and down.
27:01
Speaker 1
They also found hiking poles and a fragment of bone.
27:06
Speaker 2
The one thing everybody remembers of that, you know, Michelle's last picture, right? She's standing, I got the blue jacket, ski poles and the mittens, and it's the blue hat. that blue stocking cap that she's got on. And so when the team came down and they had the pack and all that, and Erica said, I wanted to find that blue hat. That was my, you know, we were really hoping to find that, but we couldn't. And well, all right. And so we're laying all of her stuff out and we open up the backpack and open the top and here's the blue hat rolled up in a ball sitting on top of the pack.
27:44
Speaker 1
Also in the pack, a camera with a few photos. After all these years, they were still there, waiting to help fill in some of Michelle's last moments on that day, all the way back in 2005.
27:55
Speaker 2
And we can actually see in one of the pictures, she took a picture looking up at Mount of the Holy Cross, and we can pick out her partner, her hiking partner, coming down the mountain. 20 minutes. If she had sat there for 20 minutes, he would have been there. But for reasons that none of us know, she got off the trail and started down this rocky trail down into the Angelica Kular. And the very last picture on her camera is a picture of a rock face. And from there, we know it was only about maybe a five-minute hike further down the slope to where she ultimately fell. And what we think happened is she was maybe trying to down climb, it was a steeper area, maybe trying to down climb there and a rock cut loose.
28:54
Speaker 1
The photos answered some questions, but they raised others. Like, why did Michelle leave that main trail?
29:02
Speaker 2
That we're all still baffled by. Why did she go down? It's a steep, narrow gully. She was on the North Trail. wide open, right where she was supposed to be. And for reasons that elude all of us, she decided to go down the ridge versus the normal trail. And that's where we're all stuck.
29:36
Speaker 1
After the discovery, the rescue team made one last trek for Michelle's remains. And in October 2024, they brought her down the mountain so her husband Ben and their children could finally say goodbye. Analysis by a forensic anthropologist would later confirm that the fracture on her spine was consistent with a fall.
29:59
Speaker 2
This was the They got everybody to crying. They found her right humerus and scapula. And there looked like there was a little wire across the scapula. And they almost thought it was just, you know, a piece of trash. They pulled it out and it was a little lavender bead necklace that was wrapped around the bones. And we took a picture of it and sent it to Ben and And he said, that's the necklace I bought for her when we were in the Virgin Islands. So that, yeah.
30:34
Speaker 1
Wow.
30:34
Speaker 2
That got everybody boo-hooing.
30:37
Speaker 1
Oh, I bet. And what was that like for you, breaking the news to her family that they could finally bring her home?
30:46
Speaker 2
That's the wild part. So this was on a Saturday, and I get a call from Ray and Judy, Michelle's mom and dad.
30:55
Speaker 1
Mm-hmm.
30:55
Speaker 2
And they called me up and said, hey, you know, we're coming up to Vail. We're going to, you know, wanted to do some shopping. And they said, can we take you out for lunch?
31:05
Speaker 1
Oh, and they didn't know about it?
31:07
Speaker 2
They know nothing.
31:08
Speaker 1
Wow.
31:09
Speaker 2
I mean, this is just one more part of this kind of crazy story. And I said, well, I said, I would love to meet you for lunch, but I've got some news to share. And I said, our team is in the field. They are on their way out and they have found Michelle's remains. And I said, if you want to meet me at the ranger station here in Minern, you can say goodbye. And they said, we will be there. And so we show up at three o'clock. The team comes out of the field. And one of the members of the team, Anya is her name. She's a forensic anthropologist with the Forest Service. So she stands up and she, I mean, it was beautiful. So we have six of the team members. We have Ray and Judy. We have Michael came up, their oldest son and his fiance, and then us. And she says, I want to show you what we found. Any questions that you have, please ask. But we have found Michelle's remains.
32:21
Speaker 1
And so.
32:22
Speaker 2
She lays out all the physical remains, the bones, and identifies everything, what belonged where in her body. And I mean, it was a cry fest. We were all bawling. And it's just one of those little connections. They want to just come up and have lunch and call me to join them. Otherwise, I would never have known anything about it. And then the end result is they're able to say goodbye to their daughter. And, um, Yeah.
32:58
Speaker 1
Yeah. I can see your, your emotional, just, you know, recounting it. It's.
33:03
Speaker 2
And then we asked to, uh, if they wanted us to go back and, you know, continue searching. And they said, you know, we've got, we've got Michelle back. That's, that's enough for us. Please don't put anybody, don't put anybody else at risk.
33:19
Speaker 1
How is this experience or has this experience affected changed the way you view the world or your own faith?
33:34
Speaker 2
I have a whole new appreciation for mystery. Lutherans tend to be very, you know, we're up in our heads a lot. You know, theology is very important. This has opened up a whole new mystery, wonder, surprise. Um, I did, I did tell the Lord, please don't do this to me again. Just kidding. Um, yeah, I, I think, I, I think I, I hold the world more lightly. I don't grasp. It's more, it has been an incredible journey. And, um, I, I am very grateful for, for the strong support of family and teammates and people who believe that there's something here. Let's, you know, the gals on the team, there's something here, let's chase it down. And the way, so the guy that, the guy searched for Michelle for 19 years with the women founder in three weeks.
34:49
Speaker 1
It's hard to imagine what that must have been like for Michelle's family, her kids who are now grown up, her husband who had remarried. They'd tried to move on with their lives, but without ever knowing what happened to her. And now, this bittersweet ending. I wondered if it felt like closure, a missing piece to that complicated puzzle of grief. And it's incredible to me that for all those years, the community, even people like Scott, who'd never even met Michelle... didn't give up on finding her. All that time, the Eagle County Sheriff's Office had a map of where they'd searched, hanging on the wall.
35:31
Speaker 2
And it had stayed there through three sheriffs, had kept that up there as a reminder that this person had not been found. And Sheriff Van Beek's last kind of hurrah was to take that down and give it to Ben and the family. And so Ben then brought it over to our building. We call it the cache. And we started to put little sticky notes on the map because they want to know where things were found. You know, where her remains, backpack, all that kind of stuff. And so we, there were, I don't know how many, maybe we had 15 people there, 20 people. And so we're all putting sticky notes with little arrows, you know, the backpack here and, you know, boot here. And I know Ben has that hanging in their house down in Lakewood. And then in August of 25, Ben and his family rented the Tiamo restaurant in Eagle Vale and had a big celebration, invited everybody who was, you know, part of the mission 20 years ago, as well as everybody who's, you know, was involved in the recovery. And we had a huge party, told lots of stories. And it was there that I had all these encounters with other people that Michelle knew who had also had dreams about Michelle. And Michelle had come and spoken to them. And it was like, okay, so I'm not crazy. And they talked about her kind of very deep spirituality, very, very faithful Roman Catholic, mass every Sunday, worked at the church. It's just, it's like the, I don't want to say, the veil between this world and this other world. It's thin. It's porous. And every once in a while, you know, you slip through the veil. Either from one side or the other, you know, it comes through. It's beyond my pay grade.
38:09
Speaker 1
Gone is hosted by me, Lucy Sheriff. It's produced by Daphne Chen. It's edited by Amy Gaines McQuaid. Our executive producer is Jacob Smith. Fact-checking by Arnica Robbins. Original music by Echo Shores. Sound design and mastering by Echo Mountain. Special thanks to Karen Shikurji, Christina Sullivan, Eric Sandler, and Greta Cohn. Gone is a co-production of Pushkin Industries and iHeartMedia.
Lucy Sherriff, host of the podcast Gone, is a journalist with 12 years of experience covering human rights, gender and news across the world. She has reported from countries such…