Dr. Laurie Santos
Dr. Laurie Santos is Professor of Psychology and Head of Silliman College at Yale University. Professor and podcast host Dr. Laurie Santos is an expert on human cognition and the…
Subscribe now to listen ad-free along with other exclusive member benefits from more than 20 Pushkin podcasts!
We tend to think of joy as something we have to earn. Once we land that dream job, find the perfect partner, or get our lives in order, then we’ll finally experience it. But life rarely goes according to plan. So what happens to our capacity for joy when things aren’t going our way?
In this live conversation from the Aspen Ideas Festival, Dr. Laurie is joined by Duke Divinity School professor Kate Bowler, author of Joyful, Anyway, to challenge the idea that a good life is one in which we’re always happy. They explore how our relentless pursuit of self-improvement can leave us feeling unfulfilled, why joy and suffering aren’t mutually exclusive, and how we can become more open to unexpected moments of delight in everyday life.
Experts Mentioned
Resources Mentioned
Related Episodes
Pushkin.
00:14
Speaker 2
Today on the Happiness Lab, we're focusing on the power of joy. Joy is a kind of funny emotion, one that often catches us completely off guard, in part because it's usually sparked by some of the most unexpected things. Maybe it's watching your kid or your cat do something ridiculous, or listening to music on shuffle when an absolute banger comes out of nowhere. But our minds also get joy wrong. We tend to think of it as an emotion we need to earn. Once we land that dream job or find our perfect partner or finally get our lives in order, then our days will be filled with joy. But as we all know, life rarely works out as planned. We experience setbacks and disappointments. We lose people we love. And sometimes, no matter how hard we try, things just don't seem to get any better. So what happens to our capacity for joy when life doesn't go our way? Well, today's guest argues that joy and pain aren't mutually exclusive. And she, of all people, would know. Kate Bowler is a professor at Duke Divinity School who spent years studying our cultural obsession with positive thinking. But when her own life took a devastating turn, she found herself questioning those ideas in a much more personal way. She's since become a four-time New York Times bestselling author, whose latest book, Joyful Anyway, questions the stories we tell ourselves about suffering, success, and what makes a good life. So as part of our series of live conversations, I'm excited to share a discussion that Kate and.
01:41
Speaker 1
I had at the Aspen Ideas Festival.
01:43
Speaker 2
Kate and I chatted about why our endless efforts to improve our lives can actually get in the way of joy, and how we can experience that wonderful feeling even when everything seems to be going wrong. Our minds are constantly telling us what to do to be happy. But what if our minds are wrong? What if our minds are lying to us, leading us away from what will really make us happy? The good news is that understanding the science of the mind can point us all back in the right direction. You're listening to The Happiness Lab with Dr. Laurie Santos. This time coming to you live from the Aspen Ideas Festival.
02:23
Speaker 3
Okay, Kate, so you are known for many things, but as a nerdy academic, one of the things I'm most excited about is to talk to you about your academic work, which is on the prosperity gospel. What is the prosperity gospel and how did you get interested in studying it?
02:38
Speaker 1
Yeah, I just kind of fell in love with, like, you know, it's an age-old story. When a woman and a prosperity gospel love each other very much, they ruin their whole 20s trying to study it. The prosperity gospel is the belief that God wants you to have health and wealth and happiness. Anything that stands in your way is just a temporary setback to those who have the right kind of faith. And I honestly had never heard about it because I grew up like an adorable, cheese-eating Mennonite in the prairies of Canada. And just Canada repping so hard. Middle powers for the not-quite-win.
03:16
Speaker 4
And.
03:17
Speaker 1
But I was in my hometown and I saw all these people pouring out on a Sunday morning of what I thought was an enormous factory. And it turns out it was not just a violation of labor laws. It was Canada's largest megachurch. And they had all just celebrated a holiday called Pastor's Appreciation Day and had given their money to a pastor who had then bought a motorcycle and drove it around on stage. And since all my Mennonite friends were going and we're supposed to be like, and pacifists and deeply committed to simplicity and furniture building. And so very loudly, I was like, nope, that is for Americans. And it turns out I was wrong, but that was the beginning of my complete obsession with what is the prosperity gospel, where did it come from, and how do I do this forever?
04:05
Speaker 3
I mean, you're making fun of Americans, which is okay because you're Canadian. But of course, one of our country's true foundational myths is this idea of having it all. We kind of have a sort of incurable optimism in this country.
04:17
Speaker 1
Where did that come from?
04:18
Speaker 2
Yeah.
04:19
Speaker 1
The prosperity gospel or the American dream? A little bit both.
04:22
Speaker 2
Yeah.
04:22
Speaker 4
Yeah.
04:23
Speaker 1
Well, every country has these like civic virtues baked into its earliest intent and then nurtured as a story of self-making. And I just think they're really fun by comparison. Like America is life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. Canada is hysterically boring with peace, order, and good governance. And just kind of like a sound. Like, don't dream too much. We don't have taxation rates for that. And so I just think the American dream is just one of these founding acts of cultural storytelling. about what offers people the ability to try to feel themselves tested against circumstances and to know if they're becoming truly who they were meant to be.
05:07
Speaker 3
But it's also a dangerous bit of storytelling, which is what your work has been about. Your original book, Blessed, was about how Americans become fixed on this idea that like pushing yourself and faith specifically can unlock health and happiness. And often that seems to get used in this super insidious way where it's like, oh, you're not healthy and happy? I guess you're not trying so hard or I guess you're not faithful. I mean, how has this idea been used to push for unfairness in some of the interesting ways across time?
05:32
Speaker 1
Yeah, I think that's right. I think fundamentally any kind of storytelling like that is a... I mean, what we would say in like religious world is a theodicy. It's an explanation for why bad things happen, period. There was a movement in the late 19th century called New Thought. After industrialization and so much wealth proximity... A certain kind of literature flourished in the United States around trying to explain why some people succeeded and others failed. And it rested on a religious belief that the mind was a powerful spiritual incubator and that rightly harnessed, harnessed through only spoken word, that this person could kind of co-create with God to bring things into being. And if that sounds unbelievably normal to everyone, it's because it has become the most successful set of rebrands over and over again. It started as new thought. It wove its way into self-help. and then through Pentecostalism, and then Norman Vincent Peale's power positive thinking, and then when I just thought it was about to taper off and I'd have to find a new job. Then you looked on TikTok. Gen Z. It's back manifesting. Exactly. Yeah. So Gen Z ruined my life and remade it. So that's what happened. I'll nerd out for a second.
06:47
Speaker 3
I teach this big happiness class on campus at Yale and we go through the evidence showing that manifesting doesn't work psychologically.
06:53
Speaker 2
It actually makes you less likely to get to your goals when you're trying to manifest.
06:56
Speaker 3
And this is the thing I get most Yale student hate about is big, long line of Yale students be like, but what if you manifest correctly?
07:01
Speaker 2
And what if you just have vision board? And what if it's like, they're so into it.
07:05
Speaker 5
And this.
07:06
Speaker 1
It's funny.
07:06
Speaker 3
I mean, I think it's funny that Yale students are very into manifesting, but in some ways it's funny that you've become so famous for your critique of the prosperity gospel, because if anyone was watching your life or reading your memoir, I think they would think.
07:18
Speaker 1
That you would be a huge fan.
07:20
Speaker 3
Cause like for a long, long time, your life kind of like Worked out, married to your high school sweetheart, became a professor at an awesome place, really young in a field where like nobody gets a professor job.
07:30
Speaker 2
Everything was going awesome. And then something interesting changed when you were in your 30s.
07:35
Speaker 1
What happened? Yeah, I had this like lovely season in the sun. And then all of a sudden I started having, it was just one of those seasons where like I couldn't get back up. Like at first it was two years of chronic pain that led to me not being able to use my arms anymore. right when I first got my job, which was not a stunning first impression when you're like, no, no, my job is to write books, even though I can't write books. And there was so much like performative, I can do it, I swear to you. Like I will prove to you that I will always get back up. And then it kind of seemed like I could just manage it all. I had that gorgeous, smushy little baby and I felt like It was the ironic embodiment of this hashtag blessed life that I spent so much time lovingly deconstructing. And then I started having stomach pain and I went to the ER over and over again and kept getting turned away with Pepto-Bismol and stories about how like maybe it was the big job making me really stressed. And then one day I just said like, it was like truly unbearable. I'm not leaving until you get me another scan. And then the very next day they called me at my office to say that I had stage four colon cancer and that I would have to go to the hospital right away. And it was like, it was, it was like a, it was like an avalanche. It was like the end of a whole world that I really loved. That's awful.
09:03
Speaker 2
I'm so sorry you had to go through that. Give me a sense of where things are now.
09:08
Speaker 4
Yeah.
09:09
Speaker 1
Well, at first I tried to act like I was starring in a reality show about a woman who gets cancer, but is like really grateful for the lessons she's learning along the way.
09:19
Speaker 2
I hope you had a TikTok account while you're doing that.
09:23
Speaker 1
It was a really long stretch where we thought I would die that summer. And so time became really surreal. Like at first it was two month scans and I was enrolled in a clinical trial that if I responded to the drug, I would get another two months. And I did that for, I mean, it just went from two months to two months to two months. And then we thought I would make it to Christmas and then I would be three months. And then by the time it got to six month scans, I felt like, all right, maybe chronic cancer is just going to be a long-term condition. And then by the time I got to five years, it's the weirdest thing that when something awful happens, there's news, there's a call. But when good news happens, no one shows up at your door to be like, hey, just so you know, time to look at your retirement plan, which you completely abandoned. So it was, uh, I'm almost 10 years out and for five years it felt, yeah, it's been, it's been a slow unveiling and all of it was a renegotiation with time and what we think is possible.
10:32
Speaker 2
And I think what's so interesting about your story is you might, you know, in the kind of movie version of it, you know, you're five years out and the credits roll and that's it.
10:40
Speaker 1
And we all walk away with a smile on our face.
10:42
Speaker 3
But one of the things that might be surprising to folks listening is that your book talks about how in some ways this was like a tough moment, a tough outcome.
10:50
Speaker 2
In your book, you talk about how you had to go back just to life again.
10:53
Speaker 4
Yeah.
10:54
Speaker 2
What do you mean by that?
10:56
Speaker 1
There's like a strange urgency there. to tragedy where it's like it suddenly paints everything in really bright colors and it felt for a while like just falling in love with the world again and also I just never sat through faculty meetings ever again yeah you know I was just like I don't think I have time for this um then eventually I have to go back and be like sorry guys but it was like apocalyptic time where you feel like all of a sudden whatever you thought was the end of the world like came to your door when it slowly becomes just a Tuesday again it just reminded me of the very first thing I said to my dad when he was like driving me away from the hospital when I just was first diagnosed I just said like hey I'm not really sure how to do this anymore and he's like what do you mean I was like I I just think like live And it's, it felt the same way with time. Like if I have so much more, am I allowed to be gossipy and ungrateful and wasteful and on social media scrolling for no apparent reason? Like being a person who has a sense of like faithful responsibility to myself and to others, I felt like any kind of like failure to appreciate that probably just might make me a bad person.
12:12
Speaker 3
It must have been such a thing that was messing with your mind, too, I think, given your academic work. You have this interesting dual lens on this idea, right, where you've studied cultural optimism and the fact that it has these cultural mechanics and it's kind of yucky. But you also personally are experiencing this moment where you are forced by a culture and everyone around you to feel this unhealthy optimism, to be kind of prodded into gratitude.
12:35
Speaker 1
Yes.
12:36
Speaker 2
But yet you're looking at the fragility of everything. How did you deal with that? Yeah.
12:41
Speaker 1
I think that's why I'm so invested in trying to understand and lovingly deconstruct cultural myths is because I'm the most susceptible to them. If you tell me to be grateful and then I start my gratitude journal and then I only find out later that gratitude has limited benefits....
13:00
Speaker 2
Data are that it helps lots of people, but you really have to feel it doesn't work for everybody.
13:05
Speaker 1
It does not work for people going through catastrophic issues. It works for people who are mostly fine. This, this is a hit.
13:12
Speaker 4
Yeah.
13:12
Speaker 3
It's a hit on our positive psychology literature, which is they have these interventions and we think it's like for the average person on a Thursday when they didn't get a stage four cancer diagnosis. OK, well, here's another, I think, cultural myth that I know from your book that you were struggling with a lot.
13:25
Speaker 4
Right.
13:26
Speaker 3
Another cultural myth is like if you go through something really terrible, then there's a bright side, the silver lining on the other side. There's like this kind of implicit universal guarantee that somehow it's going to get easier after that.
13:40
Speaker 4
Yeah.
13:40
Speaker 2
How did that manifest for you, knowing everything that you know about all these myths?
13:44
Speaker 1
Yeah, I guess it's very hard because it is kind of the overwhelming cultural messaging you're getting all the time, like that you will inherently become a better person. What doesn't kill you isn't just going to try again tomorrow, you know, and it's hard to then find the truest way of saying what we, I think we all believe, which is there are treasures we can find in the dark. There are like beautiful, hopeful things we will have only discovered like in the crucible of great, horrible things. But that's an entirely different thing to say than like at the end of every celebrity interview. And it made me who I am today.
14:19
Speaker 2
I'm stronger now for all my terrible stuff.
14:22
Speaker 1
Looking back, I'm so grateful.
14:24
Speaker 3
And if there was maybe something that came out of this situation that was good, it was that you got very good at having a lens on that existential crisis or this kind of broader spiritual crisis. This idea of always wanting to get better, always wanting more. And that is something that we're going to talk about when we get back from the break. Kate's take on this silent yearning that so many of us have and what we can do to deal with that. The Happiness Lab.
14:46
Speaker 1
We'll be back from.
14:47
Speaker 4
The break in a moment. Welcome back to the Happiness Lab.
15:00
Speaker 3
We are so excited to be here at the Aspen Ideas Festival with the amazing Kate Bauer. One of the things your deep dive into the spiritual crisis, this existential moment taught you is that so many of us are walking around here dealing with this thing that you call the ache. Yeah.
15:17
Speaker 2
What is the ache?
15:18
Speaker 3
And can you give me some specific examples of how it might be playing out for the folks in this audience?
15:22
Speaker 1
Yeah. I mean, the ache is this sense of. bittersweet longing, this feeling like there is something, a restless missing that we wish we could have and can't seem to find. And I was just so curious of like what theological, historical, psychological language you could use to describe this feeling that isn't quite malaise because there is, um, there's just like a restless sweetness to it. And so I kind of went looking for like what words people have used. And I noticed some of them were almost like in musical language, like in the African-American tradition, like the language of the blues. And it reminded me, like, there are some truths we can only tell about ourselves in a minor key. You know, it's still a song. And in Portuguese, it's saudade. And I really liked Frederick Schiller's, there's always a German word for something, should be a t-shirt we all have. But he called it zensucht, like bittersweet longing. You know, I was always taught in a Christian framework that an incompleteness is a kind of spiritual hole that then gets filled if you're a good and faithful person. So as someone who just like really considers herself pretty Jesus-y and did not feel said miraculous completion all the live long day, I kind of went looking for what other framework we might use.
16:41
Speaker 2
It seems like part of this ache is something that we just like don't accept as humans, this idea that.
16:45
Speaker 1
We are finite.
16:46
Speaker 2
We are limited by bodies and time.
16:48
Speaker 3
This is something that the journalist Oliver Berkman talks about a lot. We had a great episode where he talked about just that we need to come to terms with the fact that we're all going to die and that this is temporary. This is just a few minutes that you're going to get out of a finite number.
16:59
Speaker 1
Not great. He's like, you will never get zero inbox. Yeah.
17:03
Speaker 4
Emotionally.
17:04
Speaker 1
Literally.
17:04
Speaker 2
Yes. Yeah.
17:06
Speaker 3
But you talked about a conversation you had with a friend, a priest friend that I found so important.
17:10
Speaker 2
Share this conversation with the group here and everyone listening at home.
17:13
Speaker 1
He's a professor and a priest, Ron Rollheiser, who also had advanced cancer and was the kind of old man who would like tolerate no guff, no nonsense from me. So when I called him and I was like, I don't really know how to describe this kind of restless incompleteness in a way that just doesn't look like failing to be grateful or failing to be faithful. And he said like, okay, look, I'm not saying there's not something wrong with you specifically, but it's likely that the thing that you feel is wrong with you is probably the same thing that's wrong with all of us, which is that there is, you know, we're born crying. There's a lot of crying in the middle. There sure is a lot at the end. So what is this bittersweet longing inside of us? he said, well, there's two ways you can put it. There's the kind of hungry, hungry hippos way where you can sort of more, more, more. Yeah. It's like snack forever. Be this voracious, endless capitalist self-making project forever. Basically live in our midlife crisis version in which there should always be something that solves this problem. He said, or we can look at the tradition and decide that this too has a kind of holy quality to it, that this is a kind of aliveness that we can direct our as we will. And if we could move it toward a sense of not just that hunger is an incompleteness, but hunger is a kind of awakeness, what then could we discover?
18:38
Speaker 2
And the problem is that we don't like to sit with that hungry, hungry hippos feeling very long. And so we want to like fill the hole with something. I know the thing I use to fill my ache is to turn to work. And it turns out we have this in common. You try to do this too.
18:52
Speaker 3
Explain the pros and cons of how work can actually turn down the existential ache a little bit and what we often might get wrong.
18:59
Speaker 1
Yeah. Actually, Laura, can I ask you? What did you find about how... Because obviously this feels a lot like vocation and purpose and it's got like... beautiful pieces to it, but sometimes might like turn down the battery of... Oh, in the trench.
19:12
Speaker 2
I mean, I'm working on this and we're all, you know, podcast hosts, happiness experts, we're all a.
19:16
Speaker 1
Work in progress.
19:16
Speaker 2
But for me, when I feel the existential angst, it's so sad. It's refreshing my inbox.
19:22
Speaker 3
Even if I just like refreshed it like 42 seconds ago, I'm like, maybe there's something that promotes my worth or something for me to do to distract myself. Oh my gosh, you want me to review this paper?
19:31
Speaker 4
Perfect.
19:32
Speaker 2
Like 45 minutes later, the ache is back.
19:35
Speaker 1
And so.
19:36
Speaker 2
You're laughing because I'm so with you.
19:38
Speaker 1
I'm so with you. Because there's been times in which work, I mean, work made me a feminist. It introduced a limitation where I was allowed to make a boundary in which I wasn't endlessly fed into ever else's needs. It also really helped me as a cancer patient when I didn't want to feel eclipsed by something I didn't choose. And so, I mean, I was ridiculous, but I was in the hospital in Atlanta every week for like a in two years it was every Wednesday all day it felt the smell the taste the everything of the hospital just it was awful and so I just decided what if this was also my workspace and so I was interviewing um I was working on televangelism and uh like lady televangelists at the time and there's all these megachurches in Atlanta so I would invite megachurch ladies to my office and And I interviewed them. I'd be like, thank you, come on in, draws curtain. And she's just like looking around like, what is wrong with you? And I'd be like, no, tell me everything, but like quickly. It looked alarming because it was, but to do this, it gave me a sense of agency and purpose. But at other times in my life, it does feed this endless buzzy churn in which I can't just be a person to be loved. I have to be constantly a person who earns my worth and my place.
21:00
Speaker 2
It never gives you a chance to just sit and look at it, right? Just look at the pain of it. I think this is something we see in.
21:05
Speaker 1
Modern culture a lot.
21:06
Speaker 2
And because we're here at Aspen Ideas, I can't help but bring up a different thing we do to deal with the ache, which is we think we're going to fix it. There's some app.
21:14
Speaker 3
There's some technology, maybe it's an AI tool that's going to like stop it. And you talk about at various events like this that you've been at meeting these so-called often guys, unfortunately, that you call Pumas.
21:26
Speaker 1
Who are the Pumas and.
21:27
Speaker 2
What are they getting wrong? And apologies to any of the Pumas in the audience.
21:31
Speaker 1
I'm always at a dinner with like very fit men in puffy vests. who have like bio wearables and they're always optimizing things that I didn't know we could optimize. Happy maxing, life maxing.
21:42
Speaker 3
Yes.
21:42
Speaker 2
Yes.
21:43
Speaker 1
They only will invest core memories with their kids. I'm like, but what about the rest of the time? Um, it's such a deep. desire to create an algorithm and a metric around this hunger and this want. It's a kind of everything is possible-ism. This is one, I think, of the great diseases of modernity that Charles Taylor really helped us kind of like get our hands around is how did we stop being people and start becoming projects?
22:11
Speaker 3
I mean, I think the wellness industry kind of helped that because when you have folks telling you, oh, there's an app to turn yourself into a project, here's this extrinsic reward that you can pay attention to and level up. You know, we just have a psychology that just gets sucked into that stuff. The other thing our psychology sucks us into is just this idea that negative emotions are bad. on the podcast and with my students, I talk a lot about toxic positivity. But your book uses a phrase from the psychologist Lisa Damwar that the idea of mental health is really feeling what is appropriate.
22:40
Speaker 1
How has a phrase.
22:42
Speaker 2
Like that helped you navigate your own pain going through this tough time and fight this idea of toxic positivity?
22:48
Speaker 1
Because there's a pathologizing of all negative emotion, there's an emotional spiral it creates where the second we worry that we're not being thrilled and grateful that we begin to demonize reality. I love Lisa Demore, who's like a big Aspen Ideas favorite and mental appropriateness. I am sad because this was devastating. I am angry because this was enraging. I find all of that like returns me to a sense of being a reliable narrator of my own life in a world where if you look at somebody else, they might just tell you to like zip it up.
23:23
Speaker 3
It's also important to just remember that those signals are there as something that's evolutionary really important, right? We forget that the feeling of sadness we get looking at all the catastrophes happening.
23:34
Speaker 5
Normative.
23:35
Speaker 3
You're a human that's built to fill that stuff. If you have too much on your plate and you feel overwhelmed, normative. This is like you're putting your hand on a hot stove and you feel pain. It doesn't feel great, but it's an awesome reaction to be like, you must take your hand off the stove.
23:47
Speaker 1
Something needs to change.
23:48
Speaker 2
All of those negative emotions are telling us something different.
23:51
Speaker 1
Super important.
23:52
Speaker 2
But when we're like, nope, can't do that. Let me go back to my like happiness to do list.
23:56
Speaker 1
We kind of lose something so important. That's right. And I think too, we get into a loop like that because we know how much our sadness costs people. I mean, We feel it when we see pain in our own kids is that we would do anything to take it away. And we feel that when we're in pain, that there is now a circle of people around us who are anxious, who are worried, who it might cost. And I think one of the first deeply wrong things that I believed the second I got sick was bad things haven't just happened, but that I am the bad thing. And I think because, you know, everything around illness is like, or any kind of undoing is like, is expensive and exhausting and usually chronic and limps along, it's easy to just start to believe that everyone else is judging you for your own pain.
24:45
Speaker 3
And so real life has these negative moments.
24:48
Speaker 1
It has the ache.
24:49
Speaker 3
We can't solve it by overworking or kind of banishing negative emotions forever.
24:53
Speaker 2
What should we do to deal with it?
24:55
Speaker 3
And spoiler, when we get back from the break, we're going to hear Kate's solution, which is that we have to become joyful anyway.
25:01
Speaker 1
The Happiness Lab will be.
25:02
Speaker 3
Back from Aspen Ideas in just a moment.
25:05
Speaker 5
Thank you.
25:15
Speaker 4
Welcome back to the Happiness Lab here at Aspen Ideas.
25:19
Speaker 2
So Kate, your book, Joyful Anyway, starts with this observation that the modern world has experienced a global withering in our capacity for joy.
25:30
Speaker 1
Ouch.
25:31
Speaker 2
What do you mean and what are some of the symptoms of this withering?
25:34
Speaker 1
I think we wake up and we look at our phones and the headlines have already convinced us that we are probably drowning in microplastics and that no one is testing the strength of highway bridges and that the fissures underneath our democracy are irreparable and your cousin's probably mad at you and you haven't fixed that yet. And there's just this like looming sense of light apocalypse happening. that feels like everything is our responsibility and yet nothing can be done. And I think it has convinced us that something like joy, it would just be like, utterly inappropriate. Like it just makes you want to be like, look around lady. You want us to be joyful now in this economy. You could just add in this economy to anything, to any sentence. Yeah. Yeah.
26:27
Speaker 2
Yeah.
26:27
Speaker 3
Well, this is like for somebody who studies the science of happiness is always so sad to me because there's actual work looking at who are the people who are trying to solve all this terrible stuff about the world, and they tend to be the people who are joyful. Georgetown researcher Konstantin Khrushchev has these lovely studies of who are the people that are going out to a climate protest or a social justice rally, and it's the people who have the bandwidth, and those are the people who experience a lot of positive emotion, who experience joy. But the problem is, especially with the ache and in the world we face, we tend to go after joy in the wrong way.
26:59
Speaker 1
I think we tend to go joy maxing.
27:01
Speaker 3
And you give us some strategies to avoid some of these errors. One of the ones that you talk about a lot is that we sometimes go too big when it comes to joy.
27:10
Speaker 2
We're like, try to peel off too much. How can we do that a little more effectively?
27:15
Speaker 1
I think we probably have something in our mind like skydiving or our family not fighting at the next reunion or just some kind of like utopian vision. But really, joy is so much more realistic than that. It has like a really distinct psychological profile. It will feel like a big, bright, enlivening feeling. It will feel like a moment of temporary wholeness. Just a moment of yes, yes, it is so good to be alive. And it doesn't have to be, like I have gone jumping off a mountain with a big sailing thing here and attached to a person named Tompk who did not think I was funny at all. I was monologuing because I was afraid. But it could just be something as dumb as the other day I was... In my living room when I could hear my son talking to my dad and my dad spent most of my whole life being deeply depressed. And the fact that he is best friends with the kid I never thought I could have. And I can hear that they are really worried about Winston Churchill and how it felt for him.
28:27
Speaker 2
In the darkest hour.
28:34
Speaker 1
It's just like this stupid laugh where you're like, what is going on? And it is this surge of delirious temporary, oh my gosh, isn't it so good to be alive?
28:45
Speaker 3
But the moment you just described gets at something I think that is tough for joy, which is like, especially in our kind of happy maxing culture, we want to engineer it And be hard to engineer the conversation with your dad and Winston Churchill. We just have to kind of be ready for it. We need to be open to the serendipity.
29:01
Speaker 2
How can we do that a little bit better without getting into like, I must schedule it mode.
29:05
Speaker 4
Yes.
29:05
Speaker 1
And I think too, just realizing it's how distinct it is from the incremental good feelings of happiness, that happiness will feel like a kind of ease that it will be built out of context, like a beautiful breeze, smart, cool people around you. Like It will feel like it has to be built up by a lot of small details. And what's lovely about and very annoying about joy is that it is a surprise, meaning you can't fix it, engineer it, max it. I wish I had my aura ring predicted.
29:41
Speaker 2
It will sneak up on you.
29:42
Speaker 1
And in that way, you kind of have to start to believe in joy. Like you used to believe in Santa Claus, like there is something coming and it is because you're built with this unbelievable capacity for it that we are actually made for joy.
29:59
Speaker 3
You've also talked about things we can do to become a little bit more ready to experience joy because of course it's serendipitous, but with all serendipity, there's ways you can kind of make yourself open to it or not. So how are some ways that we can embrace this readiness for joy?
30:11
Speaker 4
Yeah.
30:11
Speaker 1
Some of the preconditions for joy, one is hilariously, wonderfully negative, and that is to try to be more honest about the life that is. And I've done that by embracing my deep, pile of resentments. And because by middle age, I realized more things had happened to me than I had chosen. And that I had rarely had a moment to account for what had happened and what had been lost. So my best friend and I started making this horrible thing called the list where we listed everything that changed us, scarred us, wish we could be different. And in making this list, like a moment where you don't moralize or sweeten the ending, a moment where you don't say, and it made me who I am today. Yep. I think if you want to be someone that joy is more likely to happen to, it might be worth stopping for a moment to see if there's any calcified pain that might become a kind of joy blocker. So I do think hilariously embracing honesty and a sense of like the cost of your life is a very good place to start. I do also think that a lot of what we talk about here about becoming more embodied, because now we know that You can't be happy and sad at the same time, but you can be joyful and sad because it has this incredible ability to engage both our dopamine and our stress system. So if we don't then think that sadness or sorrow is a joy killer, it's actually compatible with the ability to be joyful. Then it's really weirdly, the joy killers are things that make us really head down and predictable and unsurpriseable. And so I think hyper-optimization might accidentally move joy to the side.
31:56
Speaker 3
Yeah, you also talked about something about getting away from this hyper-optimization in your book that as a lapsed Catholic, I really resonated with, which is this idea that we have to embrace ordinary time. Ordinary time for the non-Catholics is the weird time. There's like Christmas time where there's like lots of stuff happening. There's like the pre-Easter time where there's lots of stuff happening. And then the Catholic calendar is like, Well, then it was just ordinary time, just like the regular time.
32:18
Speaker 1
You're on your own.
32:19
Speaker 3
There's no candles or nothing exciting is happening. But your idea is like, that's the time. That's the time we need to pay attention to. And so what are some pieces of advice to embrace joy in these ordinary moments?
32:30
Speaker 1
Yeah. Yeah, some of it is because there's sort of like things that you can look for that are kind of hiding around joy. And one is a kind of anything that engenders a sense of hope, because hope will shout down despair. Hope will be the thing that tells you that. yes, the terrible thing happened, but might not again, beautiful things are still in store for you.
32:51
Speaker 3
And I think you mean specifically hope without that denial component, not hope, but like the American prosperity gospel optimism, like I'm doing great.
32:58
Speaker 2
So everything's going to be perfect. It's like hope with the reality of all the BS in life.
33:02
Speaker 1
That's right.
33:03
Speaker 2
Yeah.
33:04
Speaker 1
To like stretch the idea of your own goodness out into a future you can't predict. And then delight because it's supposed to light us up and it's just for us. That's what's so funny and dumb about joy is it is like for you. It's not just like standard issue, like a horrible Mennonite Christmas where like you get tube socks, you get tube socks, everyone gets tube socks. Like it is really your own weird and beautiful thing. And what's funny about gratitude is it will, even if you can't always gratitude your way into it, it will make you say, thank you. It is so good to be.
33:36
Speaker 3
And even just the idea of finding delights has always struck me as like so much easier than finding the things you're grateful for.
33:42
Speaker 2
Gratitude feels really heavy, but delight is like, I walked by that car and that dude was rocking out to Motley Crue.
33:47
Speaker 1
Like that's a delight. And like now I'm.
33:49
Speaker 3
Experiencing the joy and savoring and happy, but it didn't have to be like, I'm so grateful for my career.
33:54
Speaker 2
Yeah.
33:55
Speaker 3
Yeah.
33:55
Speaker 1
It doesn't have to be, but it is part of like our endless journey. storytelling about ourself is like I am the kind of person like whatever happened I'm still the kind of person that can be lit up the kind of person that can be like surprised by laugh I can still find a small yes when I would really rather say no I'm something can be new.
34:16
Speaker 3
Again Kate, thank you for helping all the folks at Aspen Ideas and all the folks listening on this podcast to find that light again. Everyone, can we give a huge Aspen Ideas Happiness Lab thank you to Kate Bowler.
34:31
Speaker 2
If you want more of Kate Bowler and her ideas in your life, and really, how could you not? Check out her award-winning podcast, Everything Happens, and her new book, Joyful Anyway. Huge thanks to the Aspen Ideas Festival for making this conversation possible. Next week, we're continuing our series of live conversations from the past year with another remarkable story about finding joy in the face of adversity. I'll be speaking with Paralympian, disability advocate, and shark attack survivor, Allie Truitt, about how she rebuilt her life after trauma and what it takes to reimagine a future for yourself when the one you planned is no longer possible.
35:09
Speaker 5
I felt like I had lost a lot in the attack that I was never getting back. And if there were things on the table that I could fight to reclaim, then I was going to fight tooth and nail for them.
35:21
Speaker 2
That's all next week on The Happiness Lab with me, Dr.
35:24
Speaker 1
Laurie Santos.
Dr. Laurie Santos is Professor of Psychology and Head of Silliman College at Yale University. Professor and podcast host Dr. Laurie Santos is an expert on human cognition and the…